Beating in Vibration Analysis: Causes and Identification

Definition: What is a Vibration Beat?

In the context of vibration analysis, a beat or beating is a distinctive phenomenon characterized by a periodic rise and fall in the amplitude of a vibration signal. This modulation occurs when two separate vibration signals of very close, but not identical, frequencies are present at the same time and combine with each other. The resulting time waveform looks like a single sine wave whose amplitude is slowly increasing and decreasing in a rhythmic pattern.

The Physics Behind Beating

Beating is a result of constructive and destructive interference. When the peaks of the two vibration waves align (in-phase), their amplitudes add together, resulting in a higher overall amplitude. When the peak of one wave aligns with the trough of the other (out-of-phase), they cancel each other out, resulting in a lower overall amplitude. This continuous cycle of reinforcement and cancellation creates the characteristic “beating” or “warbling” sound and vibration pattern.

The frequency of this amplitude modulation, known as the beat frequency, is equal to the absolute difference between the two source frequencies.

Beat Frequency = |Frequency 1 – Frequency 2|

For example, if two machines are generating vibrations at 29.5 Hz and 30.5 Hz, the resulting beat frequency will be |29.5 – 30.5| = 1.0 Hz. This means the overall vibration amplitude will rise and fall once every second.

Common Causes of Beating in Industrial Machinery

The presence of a beat frequency is a valuable diagnostic clue because it points to the existence of two closely spaced driving frequencies. Common sources in industrial settings include:

• Multiple Machines on a Common Structure: The most classic example is two pumps or fans with identical designs running on the same platform or piping system. If their operating speeds are slightly different (e.g., 1780 RPM and 1785 RPM), they will produce a low-frequency beat.
• Electric Motors: Beating can occur between the rotational frequency of the motor and an electrical frequency, such as the pole pass frequency in an induction motor.
• Multi-stage Pumps or Compressors: Interaction between different stages that are running at slightly different effective speeds.
• Gearboxes: Interaction between two gear meshes with a similar number of teeth.
• Hydraulic or Aerodynamic Pulsations: Interaction between two different sources of flow-related turbulence.

How to Identify Beating in Vibration Data

Time Waveform Analysis

The time waveform is the most direct way to observe beating. The signal will show a clear, repeating pattern of amplitude modulation. The time between two consecutive amplitude peaks (or troughs) is the period of the beat frequency.

Frequency Spectrum (FFT) Analysis

In the frequency spectrum, a beat will appear as two distinct peaks located very close to each other. A standard FFT might not have enough resolution to separate them, making them appear as a single, broad peak. To properly diagnose a beat, the analyst must use a high-resolution FFT (by increasing the number of spectral lines). This will clearly resolve the two individual frequency components that are causing the beat.

Is Beating a Problem?

Beating itself is not a fault, but rather a symptom of interacting frequencies. However, it can be problematic:

• Annoying Noise: The rising and falling sound can be more noticeable and irritating to personnel than a constant noise.
• Peak Amplitude Concerns: The maximum amplitude during the constructive interference phase can be nearly double the amplitude of the individual signals. This peak level might exceed alarm limits or cause excessive stress on components, even if the average vibration is acceptable.
• Masking Other Issues: The fluctuating signal can sometimes make it difficult to identify other underlying vibration problems.

Resolving a problematic beat typically involves identifying the two source frequencies and attempting to either change the speed of one of the machines or introduce damping to mitigate the amplitude peaks.

← Back to Main Index