Understanding API 684 Standard
Definition: What is API 684?
API 684 (American Petroleum Institute Standard 684: “API Standard Paragraphs Rotordynamic Tutorial: Lateral Critical Speeds, Unbalance Response, Stability, Train Torsionals, and Rotor Balancing”) is a comprehensive tutorial document providing guidance, recommended practices, and theoretical background for performing rotor dynamics analysis on turbomachinery. Unlike prescriptive specifications, API 684 is educational—explaining how to analyze critical speeds, predict unbalance response, assess stability, evaluate torsional vibration, and establish balancing requirements for equipment covered by other API standards (API 610 pumps, API 617 compressors, API 612 steam turbines).
API 684 serves as the theoretical foundation and analytical guide supporting the vibration requirements in other API equipment standards, providing the “how and why” of rotor dynamic analysis methods, acceptance criteria derivation, and troubleshooting approaches for rotating equipment engineers and analysts.
Standard Structure
Part 1: Tutorial on Lateral Rotor Dynamics
- Critical Speed Analysis: Methods for calculating lateral critical speeds
- Unbalance Response: Predicting vibration from unbalance
- Stability Analysis: Assessing rotor stability margins
- Modeling Techniques: Finite element and transfer matrix methods
- Acceptance Criteria: How to judge if analysis acceptable
Part 2: Tutorial on Train Torsional Analysis
- Torsional Natural Frequencies: Calculation methods
- Forced Response: Prediction from excitation sources
- Transient Analysis: Startup, shutdown, fault conditions
- Acceptance: Stress limits, separation margins
Part 3: Tutorial on Rotor Balancing
- Balance Criteria: ISO balance grades application
- Shop Balancing: Procedures and tolerances
- Field Balancing: In-situ methods
- Flexible Rotor Balancing: Special considerations
Key Concepts Addressed
Separation Margins
- Operating speed should be ±15-20% from critical speeds minimum
- Larger margins for low-damping systems
- Guidance on evaluating adequacy
Damping Requirements
- Minimum damping levels for safe operation
- Log decrement criteria
- Amplification factor limits at critical speeds
Stability Criteria
- Analysis methods for predicting onset of instability
- Threshold of stability determination
- Bearing selection for stability
Practical Application
Design Phase
- Perform rotor dynamic analysis per API 684 methods
- Predict critical speeds and response
- Document analysis in vendor documentation
- Purchaser reviews and approves
Commissioning
- Compare actual vibration to predictions
- Verify critical speeds within predicted range (±15%)
- Confirm unbalance response matches calculations
- Validate Campbell diagrams
Troubleshooting
- Use API 684 guidance for problem diagnosis
- Modify rotor dynamic models based on test data
- Evaluate proposed modifications
- Predict effects before implementation
Relationship to Other API Standards
API 617 (Compressors)
- References API 684 for rotor dynamics requirements
- Specifies that analysis must follow API 684 methods
- Acceptance criteria derived from API 684 principles
API 610 (Pumps)
- Critical speed and rotor dynamics requirements reference API 684
- Balancing specifications based on API 684
API 612 (Steam Turbines)
- Rotor dynamics analysis per API 684
- Lateral and torsional analysis requirements
Benefits and Value
Standardized Approach
- Common methodology across industry
- Consistent analysis quality
- Facilitates communication between parties
- Enables comparison between vendors
Educational Resource
- Tutorial format explains concepts
- Not just requirements but understanding
- Training tool for engineers
- Reference for best practices
Proven Practices
- Based on decades of industry experience
- Incorporates lessons learned
- Reduces risks from inadequate analysis
- Improves equipment reliability
Implementation
Who Performs Analysis
- Equipment manufacturers (OEMs)
- Engineering contractors
- Specialized rotor dynamics consultants
- End-user engineering departments
- Requires specialized software and expertise
Deliverables
- Rotor dynamics report
- Campbell diagrams
- Unbalance response predictions
- Stability analysis
- Torsional analysis (if applicable)
- Recommended operating speed ranges
API 684 is the authoritative tutorial and guidance document for rotor dynamics analysis in petroleum and power industries. By providing comprehensive methodology, acceptance criteria, and educational content for lateral and torsional analysis, API 684 ensures consistent, high-quality rotor dynamic assessments supporting reliable, safe operation of critical turbomachinery worldwide.