Understanding Rolling Element Defects

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,336.95 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,336.95.$2,011.55Trenutna cijena je: $2,011.55.

Parts

Vibration sensor

$106.49 Izvorna cijena bila je: $106.49.$82.83Trenutna cijena je: $82.83.

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$146.72 Izvorna cijena bila je: $146.72.$106.49Trenutna cijena je: $106.49.

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,049.74

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.43

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.83

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,052.96 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,052.96.$1,774.90Trenutna cijena je: $1,774.90.

Definition: What are Rolling Element Defects?

Rolling element defects are damage, flaws, or imperfections in the balls or rollers of rolling element bearings. These defects include surface spalls, cracks, embedded contamination, material inclusions, and geometric imperfections. When a defective rolling element rotates through the bearing, it creates impacts on both the inner and outer races, generating vibration at the ball spin frequency (BSF) with characteristic sidebands at cage frequency (FTF) spacing.

Rolling element defects are less common than race defects, accounting for approximately 10-15% of bearing failures, but when they occur, they produce distinctive vibration signatures and can progress rapidly to complete bearing failure.

Types of Rolling Element Defects

1. Surface Spalls

The most common rolling element defect:

• Cause: Rolling contact fatigue causing material to flake away
• Appearance: Crater or pit on ball/roller surface
• Size: Typically 0.5-3 mm initially, can grow larger
• Impact: Creates impacts on both races as defect strikes them
• Frequency: Generates vibration at BSF and 2×BSF

2. Cracks

• Cause: Overloading, impact damage, or fatigue
• Types: Surface cracks or subsurface cracks
• Progression: Crack propagates until piece breaks free (becoming a spall)
• Detection: Difficult to detect until spalling occurs
• Danger: Can lead to sudden catastrophic failure if ball fragments

3. Material Inclusions

• Cause: Manufacturing defects—foreign material or voids in bearing steel
• Effect: Creates stress concentration, initiates premature fatigue
• Detection: Usually not detectable until spalling develops around inclusion
• Prevention: High-quality bearing materials with clean steel

4. Embedded Contamination

• Cause: Hard particles (dirt, metal chips) pressed into ball surface
• Effect: Creates raised bump that impacts races
• Progression: Indentation becomes stress riser, may lead to spalling
• Detection: Generates impact vibration at BSF

5. Corrosion and Moisture Damage

• Appearance: Rust spots, pitting, surface roughness
• Progression: Corroded areas become fatigue initiation sites
• Prevention: Proper sealing, corrosion-inhibited lubricants

6. Brinelling and Denting

• Cause: Impact loading (dropping, shock, handling damage)
• Appearance: Permanent indentations on ball surface
• Effect: Dents create impacts and stress concentrations
• Prevention: Careful handling, proper installation procedures

Vibration Signature

Frequency Content

Rolling element defects produce distinctive patterns:

• Primary Frequency: BSF (ball spin frequency), typically 2-3× running speed
• Second Harmonic: 2×BSF often stronger than fundamental (defect strikes both races per revolution)
• Sideband Spacing: FTF (cage frequency) sidebands, NOT 1× sidebands
• Pattern: BSF ± FTF, BSF ± 2×FTF, creating “picket fence” with FTF spacing

Distinguishing Features

Feature	Outer Race Defect	Inner Race Defect	Rolling Element Defect
Primary Frequency	BPFO (3-5×)	BPFI (5-7×)	BSF (2-3×)
Sideband Spacing	None or minimal	±1× (shaft speed)	±FTF (cage speed)
Amplitude Stability	Relatively stable	Stable	Variable (depends on ball position)
Occurrence	Most common (~40%)	Common (~35%)	Least common (~10-15%)

Amplitude Variability

A characteristic feature of rolling element defects:

• Amplitude varies between measurements as defected element’s load varies
• When defected ball in load zone: high amplitude
• When defected ball opposite load zone: lower amplitude
• This variability can complicate trending but is diagnostic for ball defects

Progression and Consequences

Defect Development

1. Initiation: Small surface crack or inclusion
2. Micro-Spall: Small piece of material breaks free
3. Spall Growth: Impacts at defect edges propagate damage
4. Multiple Spalls: Secondary damage from debris creates additional defects
5. Ball Fragmentation: Severe cases, entire ball may crack and fragment
6. Complete Failure: Bearing loses load-carrying capacity

Secondary Damage

• Race Damage: Defected ball damages inner and outer race surfaces
• Debris Circulation: Spalled material creates three-body abrasion
• Cage Damage: Ball surface irregularities can damage cage pockets
• Rapid Deterioration: Once one ball damaged, others follow quickly

Common Causes

Manufacturing and Material Defects

• Internal inclusions or voids in ball material
• Improper heat treatment
• Surface finish defects
• Geometric imperfections (out-of-round balls)

Installation Damage

• Impact during handling (dropping, striking)
• Brinelling from static overload or vibration while stationary
• Contamination during installation embedding particles

Operating Conditions

• Inadequate lubrication causing surface distress
• Overloading accelerating fatigue
• Electrical current through bearing causing pitting
• Corrosive environment attacking ball surfaces
• Hard particle contamination creating indentations

Detection and Diagnosis

Vibration Analysis

• Calculate BSF and FTF for installed bearing
• Search envelope spectrum for BSF peak
• Verify FTF sideband pattern (key diagnostic feature)
• Check for 2×BSF which often has higher amplitude
• Multiple measurements may show amplitude variability

Physical Inspection

• Disassemble bearing and inspect each ball/roller individually
• Look for spalls, cracks, embedded material, corrosion
• Feel surface roughness (smooth vs. rough balls)
• Check for geometric accuracy (out-of-round)
• Photograph defects for documentation

Corrective Actions

Immediate Response

• Increase monitoring frequency based on severity
• Plan bearing replacement
• Investigate root cause to prevent recurrence
• Check for secondary damage to races

Root Cause Analysis

• Review bearing selection (adequate rating?)
• Verify lubrication adequacy
• Check for contamination sources
• Assess installation practices
• Consider upgraded bearing specification if premature failure

Rolling element defects, while less common than race defects, require understanding of their distinctive BSF frequency signature with FTF sidebands for accurate diagnosis. Early detection through envelope analysis enables planned maintenance before the defect progresses to severe bearing damage and potential catastrophic failure.

---

← Back to Main Index