Understanding Shaft Misalignment in Rotating Machinery

Definition: What is Misalignment?

Shaft misalignment is a condition where the rotational centerlines of two or more coupled shafts are not collinear when the machine is running under normal operating conditions. Along with unbalance, it is one of the most common causes of premature machinery failure, leading to increased vibration, bearing and seal damage, and excessive energy consumption. The goal of precision alignment is to bring the shaft centerlines into as close alignment as possible within specified tolerances.

Types of Misalignment

Misalignment is categorized into two primary types, although in most real-world cases, a combination of both is present.

1. Parallel Misalignment (or Offset)

Parallel misalignment occurs when the two shaft centerlines are parallel to each other but are offset by a certain distance. This can be visualized as one shaft being higher or lower (vertical offset) or further to one side (horizontal offset) than the other.

2. Angular Misalignment

Angular misalignment occurs when the two shafts are at an angle to each other. Their centerlines intersect at the point of coupling, but they are not in the same line. This creates a “gap” at the coupling that is wider at one side than the other.

3. Combined Misalignment

This is the most common scenario, where the shafts suffer from both parallel and angular misalignment simultaneously.

The Vibration Signature of Misalignment

Misalignment generates a very distinct vibration signature that can be identified in an FFT spectrum:

• Primary Indicator (2x): The most common and classic sign of misalignment is a high-amplitude vibration peak at exactly 2x the rotational speed (2nd order). This is because the forces caused by misalignment subject the shafts and coupling to two bending cycles per revolution.
• High Axial Vibration: Misalignment often produces strong vibration in the axial direction (parallel to the shaft). A high 2x peak in the axial direction is a very strong indicator of misalignment.
• Other Harmonics (1x, 3x, 4x): While 2x is the primary indicator, misalignment can also excite the 1x running speed frequency. Severe misalignment, particularly parallel offset, can also generate higher harmonics like 3x and 4x.
• Coupling-Specific Frequencies: Some types of couplings, when worn or stressed by misalignment, can generate vibration at their own characteristic frequencies.

A vibration spectrum showing a 2x peak that is 50% or more of the 1x peak, especially when accompanied by high axial vibration, is a textbook case of misalignment.

Common Causes of Misalignment

Misalignment can be present from initial installation or develop over time.

• Improper Installation: The most common cause is a lack of precision alignment during the initial machine setup.
• Thermal Growth: As machines heat up from room temperature to their operating temperature, their components expand. A motor might grow taller, or a pump casing might expand, pulling the shafts out of alignment. Precision alignment must account for this thermal growth.
• Pipe Strain: Forces from improperly supported inlet or outlet piping can pull a pump or compressor out of alignment with its driver. This is a very common issue in process industries.
• Foundation Issues: A weak or cracked foundation, or loose anchor bolts, can allow a machine to shift over time.
• Soft Foot: A condition where one of the machine’s mounting feet does not sit flat on the baseplate, causing the machine frame to be twisted or distorted when bolted down.

Why Correcting Misalignment is Critical

Running a machine misaligned has severe consequences:

• Bearing and Seal Failure: The high cyclic loads imposed on the shafts are transmitted directly to the bearings and seals, causing them to fail prematurely.
• Coupling Failure: Couplings are designed to handle a small amount of misalignment, but excessive misalignment will cause them to wear out and fail rapidly.
• Shaft Fatigue: The repeated bending of the shafts can lead to fatigue cracks and eventual shaft failure.
• Increased Energy Consumption: Significant energy is wasted in the form of heat and vibration instead of performing useful work.

Precision alignment, using tools like dial indicators or laser alignment systems, is a cornerstone of any effective reliability and maintenance program.

← Back to Main Index