Understanding Bearing Span in Rotor Dynamics

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

Complete vibration diagnostics and balancing kit from Vibromera, including four vibration sensors with cables, a signal interface module, laser tachometer with magnetic stand, digital scale, USB cable, and a carrying case. The system is designed for field rotor balancing and condition monitoring on industrial equipment.

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

Definition: What is Bearing Span?

Bearing span (also called bearing spacing or support span) is the center-to-center distance between the two main support bearings of a rotor. This geometric parameter is one of the most important factors in rotor dynamics because it directly affects the shaft’s bending stiffness, which in turn determines critical speeds, maximum deflections, bearing loads, and overall rotor dynamic behavior.

For a given shaft diameter and material, increasing the bearing span reduces stiffness (shaft becomes more flexible) and lowers critical speeds, while decreasing the span increases stiffness and raises critical speeds. This relationship makes bearing span a key design parameter in rotating machinery.

Effect on Rotor Stiffness

Beam Mechanics Relationship

The shaft between bearings acts as a beam, and its stiffness follows the fundamental beam equation:

Deflection ∝ L³ / (E × I)
Where L = bearing span (length)
E = material modulus of elasticity
I = shaft moment of inertia (proportional to diameter⁴)
Critical Insight: Deflection (and thus flexibility) increases with the cube of span

Practical Implications

Doubling the bearing span increases deflection by 8× (2³ = 8)
Reducing span by 25% reduces deflection by approximately 58%
Small changes in bearing location can have large effects on stiffness
Span is more influential than shaft diameter for long rotors

Impact on Critical Speeds

Fundamental Relationship

For a simple rotor (uniform shaft, concentrated mass at center), the first natural frequency is approximately:

f ∝ √(k/m) where k = shaft stiffness, m = rotor mass
Since stiffness ∝ 1/L³, then f ∝ 1/L^(3/2)
Practical Rule: First critical speed inversely proportional to bearing span to the 1.5 power

Design Implications

Shorter Span: Higher critical speeds, stiffer rotor, better for high-speed operation
Longer Span: Lower critical speeds, more flexible rotor, may operate as flexible rotor
Optimization: Balance between accessibility (longer span better) and stiffness (shorter span better)

Example Calculation

Consider a motor rotor with first critical speed of 3000 RPM at 500 mm bearing span:

If bearing span increased to 600 mm (20% increase):
Critical speed decreases to 3000 / (600/500)^1.5 ≈ 2600 RPM
This 13% reduction in critical speed could move it closer to operating speed

Design Considerations

Selecting Bearing Span

Engineers must balance multiple factors when positioning bearings:

Mechanical Constraints

Machine frame and housing dimensions
Rotor component locations (impellers, couplings, etc.)
Access for maintenance and assembly
Coupling and drive requirements

Rotor Dynamic Requirements

Critical Speed Separation: Position bearings to place critical speeds ±20-30% from operating speed
Rigid vs. Flexible: Shorter span keeps rotor rigid; longer span may require operation as flexible rotor
Deflection Limits: Ensure maximum deflection doesn’t cause rubs or seal damage
Bearing Loads: Longer spans reduce bearing loads for given rotor weight

Manufacturing and Assembly

Longer spans provide more access for balancing and assembly
Bearing alignment easier with visible span
Shorter spans more compact, require less frame material

Effect on Bearing Loads

Load Distribution

Bearing span affects how rotor weight and forces are distributed to bearings:

Longer Span: Lower bearing loads for same rotor weight (longer lever arm)
Shorter Span: Higher bearing loads but more even distribution
Overhung Loads: Effect of overhung components amplified with longer span

Dynamic Loads from Unbalance

Dynamic bearing loads from unbalance depend on deflection
Longer span allows more deflection, can reduce bearing loads
But also increases vibration amplitude
Trade-off between bearing life and vibration levels

Relationship to Shaft Diameter

Bearing span must be considered together with shaft diameter:

Span-to-Diameter Ratio (L/D)

L/D < 5: Very stiff, rigid rotor behavior typical
5 < L/D < 20: Moderate flexibility, most industrial machinery
L/D > 20: Highly flexible, flexible rotor considerations essential

Optimization Strategy

Fixed Span: Increase diameter to raise critical speeds
Fixed Diameter: Decrease span to raise critical speeds
Combined Optimization: Adjust both to meet critical speed and deflection requirements
Practical Limitation: Space constraints often fix one parameter

Multiple Bearing Configurations

Standard Two-Bearing Support

Most common configuration
One bearing span defines system
Simple analysis and design

Multi-Bearing Systems

Rotors with more than two bearings have multiple spans:

Three Bearings: Two spans (e.g., motor with center bearing)
Four or More: Multiple spans, complex analysis required
Effective Span: For vibration analysis, may need to determine effective span for each mode
Coupled Dynamics: Spans interact, affecting overall system behavior

Measurement and Verification

As-Built Verification

Measure actual bearing span during installation
Verify matches design specifications (typically ±5 mm tolerance)
Document as-built dimensions for rotor dynamic calculations
Check alignment of bearing centerlines

Effect of Installation Variations

Bearing position errors affect predicted critical speeds
Misalignment creates additional loads
Foundation settling can change effective span over time
Thermal growth may alter effective span at operating temperature

Modification and Retrofits

When to Modify Bearing Span

Bearing repositioning considered when:

Operating too close to critical speed (move bearing to change critical)
Excessive shaft deflection causing rubs or seal problems
Bearing loads too high or unevenly distributed
Converting from rigid to flexible rotor operation (or vice versa)

Challenges of Span Modification

Structural Changes: May require frame or housing modifications
Alignment Impact: Changed bearing positions affect alignment with driven equipment
Cost: Significant modification costs must be justified by benefits
Validation Required: Testing needed to confirm improvements

Bearing span is a fundamental geometric parameter that profoundly influences rotor dynamic behavior. Proper selection during design and accurate verification during installation are essential for achieving desired critical speed separation, acceptable vibration levels, and reliable long-term operation of rotating machinery.

← Back to Main Index