Understanding Mechanical Fatigue
Definition: What is Mechanical Fatigue?
Mechanical fatigue (also called material fatigue or simply fatigue) is the progressive, localized structural damage that occurs when a material is subjected to repeated cycles of stress or strain, even when the maximum stress in each cycle is well below the material’s ultimate tensile strength or yield strength. Fatigue causes microscopic cracks to initiate and grow over many thousands or millions of cycles, eventually leading to complete fracture without warning.
Fatigue is the most common failure mode in rotating machinery components including shafts, gears, bearings, fasteners, and structural elements. It is particularly insidious because fatigue failures occur suddenly, at stress levels that would be safe under static loading, and often without visible prior warning. Understanding fatigue is essential for safe machinery design and operation.
The Fatigue Process
Three Stages of Fatigue Failure
Stage 1: Crack Initiation
- Location: Initiates at stress concentrations (holes, corners, surface defects)
- Mechanism: Localized plastic deformation creates microscopic crack (typically < 0.1 mm)
- Duration: Can be 50-90% of total fatigue life for smooth surfaces
- Detection: Extremely difficult, usually not detectable in service
Stage 2: Crack Propagation
- Process: Crack grows incrementally with each stress cycle
- Rate: Follows Paris Law—rate proportional to stress intensity factor
- Appearance: Smooth, typically semi-circular or elliptical crack front
- Beach Marks: Concentric patterns showing crack growth stages (visible on fracture surface)
- Duration: May be 10-50% of total life
Stage 3: Final Fracture
- Crack grows to critical size where remaining material cannot support load
- Sudden, catastrophic fracture of remaining cross-section
- Fracture surface rough and irregular (contrasts with smooth fatigue zone)
- Typically occurs without warning during normal operation
Fatigue in Rotating Machinery
Shaft Fatigue
- Cause: Bending stresses from unbalance, misalignment, or transverse loads
- Stress Cycle: Rotating shaft experiences complete reversal each revolution
- Common Locations: Keyways, diameter changes, shoulders, press fits
- Typical Life: 10⁷ to 10⁹ cycles (years of operation)
- Detection: Shaft crack vibration signatures (2× component)
Bearing Fatigue
- Mechanism: Rolling contact fatigue from Hertzian stresses
- Result: Spalling of bearing races or rolling elements
- L10 Life: Statistical life where 10% of bearings fail (design basis)
- Detection: Bearing fault frequencies in vibration spectrum
Gear Tooth Fatigue
- Bending Fatigue: Cracks initiate at tooth root fillet
- Contact Fatigue: Surface pitting and spalling
- Cycles: Every mesh engagement is one cycle
- Failure: Tooth breakage or surface deterioration
Fastener Fatigue
- Bolts subjected to alternating loads from vibration
- Cracks typically initiate at first thread in nut
- Sudden bolt failure without visible warning
- Can lead to equipment collapse or separation
Structural Fatigue
- Frames, pedestals, welds subjected to cyclic loading
- Vibration creates alternating stresses
- Cracks at welds, corners, geometric discontinuities
- Progressive failure of support structures
Factors Influencing Fatigue Life
Stress Amplitude
- Fatigue life decreases exponentially with stress amplitude
- Typical relationship: Life ∝ 1/Stress⁶ to 1/Stress¹⁰
- Small reductions in stress dramatically extend life
- Minimizing vibration directly extends component fatigue life
Mean Stress
- Static (mean) stress combined with alternating stress affects life
- Higher mean stress reduces fatigue strength
- Preloaded or prestressed components more susceptible
Stress Concentrations
- Geometric features (holes, corners, grooves) concentrate stress
- Stress concentration factor (Kt) multiplies nominal stress
- Cracks almost always initiate at stress concentrations
- Design with generous radii, avoid sharp corners
Surface Condition
- Surface finish affects fatigue strength (smooth > rough)
- Surface defects (nicks, scratches, corrosion pits) initiate cracks
- Surface treatments (shot peening, nitriding) improve fatigue resistance
Environment
- Corrosion Fatigue: Corrosive environment accelerates crack growth
- Temperature: Elevated temperatures reduce fatigue strength
- Frequency: Very high or very low cycling rates can affect life
Prevention Strategies
Design Phase
- Eliminate or minimize stress concentrations (use generous fillets)
- Design for adequate fatigue margins (safety factors 2-4 typical)
- Select materials with good fatigue properties
- Finite element analysis to identify high-stress areas
- Avoid sharp corners, holes in high-stress regions when possible
Manufacturing
- Improve surface finish on critical components
- Surface treatments (shot peening, case hardening)
- Proper heat treatment for optimal fatigue strength
- Avoid machining marks perpendicular to stress direction
Operation
- Reduce Vibration: Good balance, precision alignment minimize alternating stresses
- Avoid Overload: Operate within design limits
- Prevent Resonance: Avoid operating at critical speeds
- Control Corrosion: Protective coatings, corrosion inhibitors
Maintenance
- Periodic inspection for cracks (visual, NDT methods)
- Monitor vibration for early warning of developing cracks
- Replace components at end of calculated fatigue life
- Repair surface damage promptly (can be crack initiation sites)
Mechanical fatigue is a fundamental failure mode in rotating machinery that causes sudden, often catastrophic failures from accumulated cyclic damage. Understanding fatigue mechanisms, designing to minimize alternating stresses, and maintaining low vibration levels through proper balance and alignment are essential for preventing fatigue failures and ensuring long, reliable service life of machinery components.