Understanding Machinery Protection Systems

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,353.83

Parts

Vibration sensor

$107.26

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$147.78

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,107.90

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.82

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.92

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,067.80

Definition: What is Machinery Protection?

Machinery protection (also called equipment protection or machine safeguarding) refers to monitoring and control systems that automatically detect dangerous operating conditions (vibration exceeding safe limits, excessive temperatures, abnormal pressures) and execute protective actions (alarms, shutdowns) to prevent catastrophic equipment damage, safety hazards, or environmental releases. Protection systems prioritize preventing damage over maintaining production, implementing fail-safe designs where sensor or power failures cause safe shutdown rather than continued operation.

Machinery protection is distinct from condition monitoring (which tracks equipment health for maintenance planning): protection systems provide immediate emergency response executing automatic shutdowns within seconds when critical thresholds are exceeded, while condition monitoring provides early warnings over weeks or months for planned interventions.

Protection System Components

Sensors (Permanently Installed)

• Proximity probes measuring shaft displacement
• Accelerometers on bearing housings
• Temperature sensors (RTDs, thermocouples)
• Pressure and flow transmitters
• Axial position sensors
• Typically redundant (2 or 3 sensors per measurement)

Monitoring Hardware

• Dedicated protection system processor
• Real-time signal processing
• Voting logic (2-out-of-2 or 2-out-of-3)
• Relay outputs for shutdown
• Separate from DCS/PLC for independence

Shutdown Logic and Actuators

• Hardwired trip circuits (not software-only)
• Solenoid valves for turbine trips
• Circuit breakers for motor trips
• Fail-safe design (loss of power causes trip)

API 670 Standard

Requirements for Turbomachinery

Industry standard for machinery protection:

• Mandatory for turbomachinery > 10,000 HP
• Specifies sensor types and quantities
• Defines voting logic and redundancy
• Sets alarm and trip delay times
• Requires independent from process control

Typical Sensor Configuration (Per API 670)

• Radial Vibration: 2 XY proximity probe sets (4 probes per bearing)
• Axial Position: 2 axial displacement probes
• Keyphasor: 2 phase reference sensors
• Bearing Temperature: 2 temperature sensors per bearing
• Total: 12-20 channels per machine typical

Protection vs. Condition Monitoring

Aspect	Condition Monitoring	Protection System
Purpose	Early fault detection for planning	Prevent catastrophic damage
Response Time	Hours to weeks	Seconds
Thresholds	Lower (early warning)	Higher (immediate danger)
Actions	Notifications, work orders	Automatic shutdown
Reliability	Accuracy important	Fail-safe critical
Redundancy	Optional	Mandatory

Integration

• Modern systems combine both functions
• Same sensors serve protection and CM
• Different processing and alarm levels
• Protection pathways independent and hardwired

Protection Parameters

Vibration

• Shaft Displacement: Proximity probe measurement, typical trip 25 mils (635 µm) p-p
• Bearing Housing Velocity: 0.5-0.6 in/s (12-15 mm/s) trip typical
• Acceleration: For high-frequency protection

Position

• Axial Position: Trips on excessive shaft movement (thrust bearing failure)
• Differential Expansion: Rotor vs. casing growth
• Eccentricity: Rotor position in bearing clearance

Temperature

• Bearing metal temperature (typically 110-120°C trip)
• Bearing drain oil temperature
• Winding temperatures

Voting and Redundancy

2-out-of-2 (AND Logic)

• Both sensors must agree to trip
• Prevents spurious trips from single sensor failure
• Risk: Both sensors must work (no protection if both fail)

2-out-of-3 (Majority)

• Any two of three sensors agreeing causes trip
• Best reliability (tolerates one failed sensor)
• More expensive (three sensors)
• Preferred for critical applications

Bypass and Testing

• Ability to bypass individual channels for testing/maintenance
• Cannot bypass all protective channels simultaneously
• Key-locked bypass controls
• Automatic bypass reset after time

Testing and Maintenance

Functional Testing

• Periodic full system tests (quarterly to annually)
• Simulate trip conditions
• Verify shutdown executes
• Test all redundant channels
• Document results

Sensor Calibration

• Annual or per specification
• Trip setpoint verification
• System response time testing
• Maintain calibration records

System Maintenance

• Keep sensors clean and functional
• Verify power supplies
• Check relay and actuator operation
• Update software/firmware as needed

Machinery protection systems are the safety net preventing catastrophic equipment failures through automated shutdown when dangerous conditions are detected. While condition monitoring provides early warnings for planned maintenance, protection systems deliver immediate emergency response, making them mandatory safety features on critical turbomachinery and high-value rotating equipment where failures could have severe operational, safety, or environmental consequences.

---

← Back to Main Index