What is Magnetic Pull? Unbalanced Magnetic Force in Motors • Portable balancer, vibration analyzer "Balanset" for dynamic balancing crushers, fans, mulchers, augers on combines, shafts, centrifuges, turbines, and many others rotors What is Magnetic Pull? Unbalanced Magnetic Force in Motors • Portable balancer, vibration analyzer "Balanset" for dynamic balancing crushers, fans, mulchers, augers on combines, shafts, centrifuges, turbines, and many others rotors

What is Magnetic Pull? Unbalanced Magnetic Force in Motors

Published by admin on

Understanding Magnetic Pull in Electric Motors

Definition: What is Magnetic Pull?

Magnetic pull (also called unbalanced magnetic pull or UMP) is a net radial electromagnetic force that develops in electric motors and generators when the air gap between the rotor and stator is not uniform. When the rotor is off-center (eccentric) in the stator bore, the air gap becomes smaller on one side and larger on the opposite side. Since magnetic force is inversely proportional to gap distance squared, the magnetic attraction is much stronger on the side with the smaller gap, creating a net force pulling the rotor toward that side.

Magnetic pull creates vibration at twice the electrical line frequency (120 Hz for 60 Hz motors, 100 Hz for 50 Hz motors), can deflect the rotor significantly, accelerate bearing wear, and in severe cases, lead to catastrophic rotor-to-stator contact. It represents a coupling between mechanical eccentricity and electromagnetic forces that can create positive feedback leading to progressive failure.

Physical Mechanism

Uniform Air Gap (Normal Condition)

  • Rotor centered in stator bore
  • Air gap equal around entire circumference (typically 0.3-1.5 mm)
  • Magnetic forces on all sides balance and cancel
  • Net radial force ≈ zero
  • Minimal electromagnetic vibration

Eccentric Air Gap (UMP Condition)

When rotor is off-center:

  1. Gap Asymmetry: One side has smaller gap (e.g., 0.5 mm), opposite side larger (e.g., 1.0 mm)
  2. Inverse Square Law: Magnetic force ∝ 1/gap², so force on small-gap side much stronger
  3. Net Force: Unbalanced forces don’t cancel, creating net pull toward small-gap side
  4. Magnitude: Can be hundreds to thousands of pounds even in moderate motors
  5. Direction: Always toward the side with smallest gap

Why 2× Line Frequency?

Magnetic pull pulsates at 2× electrical frequency:

  • Three-phase AC creates rotating magnetic field
  • Magnetic field strength pulsates at 2× line frequency (inherent to 3-phase systems)
  • With eccentric rotor, this pulsation creates vibration at 2×f
  • 60 Hz motor → 120 Hz vibration
  • 50 Hz motor → 100 Hz vibration

Causes of Unbalanced Magnetic Pull

Bearing Wear

  • Most common cause of developing UMP
  • Bearing clearance allows rotor to run off-center
  • Gravity pulls rotor down, reducing bottom air gap
  • UMP pulls rotor further off-center
  • Positive feedback: UMP accelerates bearing wear

Manufacturing Tolerances

  • Rotor Eccentricity: Rotor not perfectly round or not centered on shaft
  • Stator Bore Eccentricity: Stator bore not concentric with mounting surfaces
  • Assembly Errors: End bells not aligned, rotor cocked during assembly
  • Tolerances Stack-Up: Accumulation of small errors creating measurable eccentricity

Operational Causes

  • Thermal Growth: Differential expansion affecting air gap uniformity
  • Frame Distortion: Soft foot or mounting stress warping frame
  • Shaft Deflection: Load or coupling forces bending shaft
  • Foundation Issues: Settling or deterioration shifting motor position

Effects and Consequences

Direct Effects

  • Radial Force on Rotor: Continuous pull toward one side
  • Bearing Overload: One bearing carries extra load from magnetic pull
  • Vibration at 2×f: Electromagnetic vibration component elevated
  • Shaft Deflection: Magnetic force bends shaft, worsening eccentricity

Progressive Failure Mechanism

UMP can create a self-reinforcing failure cycle:

  1. Initial eccentricity (from bearing wear or manufacturing)
  2. Magnetic pull develops toward small-gap side
  3. Force deflects rotor further, reducing gap more
  4. Stronger magnetic pull from smaller gap
  5. Accelerated bearing wear on loaded side
  6. Increasing eccentricity and magnetic pull
  7. Eventual rotor-stator contact and catastrophic failure

Secondary Damage

  • Accelerated bearing failure from asymmetric loading
  • Possible rotor-stator rubs damaging both components
  • Shaft bending or permanent bow
  • Stator winding damage from rotor strikes
  • Efficiency loss from non-optimal air gap

Detection and Diagnosis

Vibration Signature

  • Primary Indicator: Elevated 2× line frequency (120 Hz or 100 Hz)
  • Typical Pattern: 2×f amplitude > 30-50% of 1× running speed vibration
  • Confirmation: Vibration at 2×f not proportional to mechanical unbalance
  • Load Independence: 2×f amplitude relatively constant with load (unlike mechanical sources)

Differentiation from Other 2×f Sources

Source Characteristics
Misalignment 2× running speed (not 2× line frequency); high axial vibration
Magnetic Pull 2× line frequency (120/100 Hz); electromagnetic origin
Stator Faults 2× line frequency; current imbalance present
Frame Resonance 2× line frequency; frame vibration >> bearing vibration

Additional Diagnostic Tests

Air Gap Measurement

  • Measure air gap at multiple locations around circumference (requires motor disassembly)
  • Eccentricity > 10% of average gap indicates problem
  • Document minimum and maximum gap values

Current Analysis

  • Measure phase currents for balance
  • Imbalance may accompany UMP
  • Spectrum shows 2× line frequency component

No-Load Test

  • Run motor uncoupled at no load
  • If 2×f vibration remains high, indicates electromagnetic source (UMP or stator fault)
  • If 2×f drops significantly, indicates mechanical misalignment source

Quantifying Magnetic Pull Force

Approximate Formula

UMP force can be estimated:

  • F ∝ (eccentricity / gap) × motor power
  • Force increases linearly with eccentricity
  • Force increases dramatically with smaller gaps
  • Larger motors produce proportionally larger forces

Typical Magnitudes

  • 10 HP motor, 10% eccentricity: ~50-100 lbs force
  • 100 HP motor, 20% eccentricity: ~500-1000 lbs force
  • 1000 HP motor, 30% eccentricity: ~5000-10,000 lbs force
  • Impact: These forces significantly load bearings and can deflect shafts

Correction Methods

For Bearing-Caused Eccentricity

  • Replace worn bearings to restore proper rotor centering
  • Use bearings with tighter tolerances if eccentricity recurring
  • Verify bearing selection adequate for motor loads including UMP
  • Check bearing fit on shaft and in end bells

For Manufacturing Eccentricity

  • Minor Cases (< 10%): Accept and monitor if vibration acceptable
  • Moderate (10-25%): Consider stator reboring or rotor machining
  • Severe (> 25%): Motor replacement or major rework required
  • Warranty: Manufacturing eccentricity may be warranty claim on new motors

For Assembly/Installation Issues

  • Verify end bell alignment and bolt torque
  • Correct soft foot conditions
  • Ensure frame not distorted by mounting stresses
  • Check for pipe strain or coupling forces pulling motor out of position

Prevention Strategies

Design and Selection

  • Specify motors with tight air gap tolerances for critical applications
  • Select quality motors from reputable manufacturers
  • Larger air gaps reduce UMP magnitude (but reduce efficiency)
  • Consider magnetic bearing designs for extreme applications

Installation

  • Careful alignment during installation
  • Verify soft foot eliminated before final bolt-up
  • Check rotor axial position and float
  • Ensure end bells properly aligned and torqued

Maintenance

  • Replace bearings before excessive wear develops
  • Monitor 2× line frequency vibration trends
  • Periodic balance and alignment verification
  • Keep motor clean to prevent cooling blockages leading to thermal distortion

Special Considerations

Large Motors

  • UMP forces can be enormous (tons of force)
  • Bearing selection must account for UMP loads
  • Shaft deflection calculations should include UMP
  • Air gap monitoring may be incorporated in large critical motors

High-Speed Motors

  • Centrifugal forces combine with UMP
  • Potential for instability if UMP too large
  • Tight air gap tolerances critical

Vertical Motors

  • Gravity doesn’t center rotor as in horizontal motors
  • UMP can pull rotor to any side
  • Thrust bearing must be adequate for rotor weight plus any UMP axial component

Relationship to Other Motor Issues

UMP and Rotor Eccentricity

  • Eccentricity causes UMP
  • UMP can worsen eccentricity (positive feedback)
  • Both create vibration but at different frequencies (1× vs. 2×f)

UMP and Stator Faults

  • Both produce 2× line frequency vibration
  • Stator faults also show current imbalance
  • UMP from eccentricity without current imbalance
  • Can coexist: stator fault AND eccentricity

UMP and Bearing Life

  • UMP adds to bearing radial loads
  • Reduces bearing life (Life ∝ 1/Load³)
  • Creates asymmetric bearing wear
  • One bearing may fail prematurely while other acceptable

Magnetic pull represents an important coupling between mechanical and electromagnetic phenomena in electric motors. Understanding UMP as the source of 2× line frequency vibration, its relationship to air gap eccentricity, and its potential for creating progressive failure through bearing overload enables proper diagnosis and correction of this motor-specific condition.

← Back to Main Index

Categories: GlossaryRotor Balancing
WhatsApp