Understanding Mechanical Loosening

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,347.12 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,347.12.$1,901.46Trenutna cijena je: $1,901.46.

Parts

Vibration sensor

$106.96 Izvorna cijena bila je: $106.96.$71.30Trenutna cijena je: $71.30.

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$147.36 Izvorna cijena bila je: $147.36.$83.19Trenutna cijena je: $83.19.

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,084.78

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.67

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.88

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,061.90 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,061.90.$1,663.78Trenutna cijena je: $1,663.78.

Definition: What is Mechanical Loosening?

Mechanical loosening is the progressive loss of clamping force, interference fit tension, or structural rigidity in properly assembled mechanical connections over time due to operating conditions, vibration, thermal cycling, material relaxation, or wear. Unlike initial looseness from improper assembly, mechanical loosening describes the gradual deterioration of connections that were initially correctly installed and torqued.

This progressive process is a significant reliability concern because it develops slowly over months or years of operation, often going undetected until vibration increases dramatically or fasteners fail completely. Understanding loosening mechanisms enables implementation of preventive measures and inspection protocols to detect and correct loosening before it causes equipment damage.

Mechanisms of Mechanical Loosening

1. Vibration-Induced Loosening

The most common mechanism in rotating machinery:

Fastener Loosening

• Mechanism: Vibration causes microscopic slip at thread interfaces
• Process: Each vibration cycle allows slight rotation of nut/bolt
• Accumulation: Thousands of cycles progressively unwind the fastener
• Critical Factors: Vibration amplitude, frequency, bolt preload, friction coefficient
• Threshold: Vibration amplitudes > 0.5-1.0 g can cause loosening over time

Self-Loosening Spiral

• Initial vibration causes slight loosening
• Looseness increases vibration (non-linear effects)
• Increased vibration accelerates further loosening
• Positive feedback can lead to rapid deterioration

2. Thermal Relaxation

Temperature effects cause loss of clamping force:

Differential Expansion

• Bolt and clamped parts have different thermal expansion coefficients or temperatures
• Heating causes expansion that can reduce bolt tension
• Cooling/heating cycles cause alternating stress (thermal ratcheting)
• Permanent bolt elongation from creep at elevated temperatures

Gasket/Seal Compression Set

• Gasket materials compress under load and temperature
• Permanent compression reduces clamped height
• Bolt tension decreases as joint settles
• Requires periodic retightening

3. Material Embedment and Settling

• Surface Roughness Crushing: Microscopic peaks on mating surfaces compress under load
• Initial Settling: Components bed together in first hours/days of operation
• Permanent Deformation: Slight plastic deformation at high-stress points
• Effect: Joint thickness decreases slightly, reducing bolt preload

4. Fretting and Wear

• Microscopic relative motion at interfaces (fretting)
• Material removed from contact surfaces
• Clearances increase over time
• Particularly at press fits and keyed connections

5. Corrosion and Chemical Attack

• Corrosion of fasteners reduces cross-section and strength
• Rust jacking can initially increase tension, then leads to failure
• Thread corrosion prevents retightening
• Galvanic corrosion between dissimilar metals

6. Fatigue

• Alternating stresses from vibration cause bolt fatigue
• Cracks develop, eventually leading to fastener failure
• Particularly problematic in high-vibration environments
• Can occur even if bolt doesn’t visibly loosen

Detection of Progressive Loosening

Vibration Trending

• Gradual increase in overall vibration levels over months/years
• Emergence and growth of harmonic components
• Increasing phase scatter in measurements
• Changes from linear to non-linear vibration response

Periodic Bolt Torque Checks

• Annual or semi-annual torque verification
• Document and trend torque values
• Torque relaxation > 20% indicates significant loosening
• Identify patterns (which bolts loosen first/most)

Physical Inspection

• Look for witness marks indicating movement
• Check for paint wear at joints
• Observe for rust streaks (indicating movement with moisture present)
• Look for fretting debris (black or reddish powder at interfaces)

Prevention Strategies

Design Measures

• Adequate Fastener Size: Larger bolts resist vibration loosening better
• Multiple Fasteners: Distribute loads and provide redundancy
• Proper Thread Engagement: Minimum 1× bolt diameter engagement
• Stiffness Optimization: Reduce vibration at source

Assembly Practices

Proper Torque Application

• Use calibrated torque wrenches
• Follow specified tightening sequence (star pattern, etc.)
• Multi-pass tightening for critical joints
• Verify final torque on all fasteners

Locking Methods

• Thread-Locking Compounds: Anaerobic adhesives (Loctite, etc.) preventing rotation
• Lock Washers: Split washers, star washers, serrated washers (effectiveness debated)
• Lock Nuts: Nylon inserts, deformed threads, staking
• Safety Wire: Positive locking for critical fasteners
• Locking Plates/Tabs: Mechanical locking features

Material Selection

• Use appropriate fastener grades (Grade 8.8, 10.9 for high loads)
• Corrosion-resistant materials for harsh environments
• Consider coatings for improved friction characteristics

Operational Practices

• Retorque After Initial Run-In: Retighten after first 24-48 hours of operation
• Periodic Verification: Check torque on schedule (annually minimum, quarterly for critical equipment)
• Vibration Control: Maintain good balance and alignment to minimize loosening forces
• Documentation: Record torque values and trending data

When Loosening Indicates Deeper Problems

Recurring loosening may indicate underlying issues:

• Excessive Vibration: Unbalance, misalignment, or resonance causing high vibration that defeats normal fastening
• Inadequate Design: Fasteners undersized or insufficient for loads
• Thermal Issues: Extreme temperature cycles or gradients
• Corrosion: Aggressive environment attacking fasteners
• Fatigue: Alternating loads exceeding fastener endurance limit

In these cases, addressing only the loosening (retightening) provides temporary relief. The root cause must be identified and corrected for permanent solution.

Mechanical loosening is an insidious process that transforms properly assembled machinery into vibrating, unreliable equipment over time. Proactive monitoring through vibration trending and periodic physical inspection, combined with proper assembly practices and locking methods, prevents loosening from compromising equipment reliability and safety.

---

← Back to Main Index