Understanding Mounting Resonance
Definition: What is Mounting Resonance?
Mounting resonance is a resonance condition where the mounting system—including vibration isolators, mounting rails, brackets, skids, or the complete equipment assembly on its supports—vibrates at one of its natural frequencies in response to excitation from the rotating machinery. This creates a situation where the entire mounted machine bounces, rocks, or oscillates as a rigid body on its mounts, with amplitudes far exceeding what would occur with rigid mounting.
Mounting resonance is particularly common in equipment using vibration isolation systems but can also occur in conventional rigid-mounted installations if the mounting structure has insufficient stiffness. The phenomenon is a key consideration in vibration isolation design and must be carefully avoided or managed through proper isolator selection and mounting system design.
Mounting System Natural Frequencies
Rigid Body Modes on Isolators
Equipment on vibration isolators has six rigid-body natural frequencies:
Translational Modes (3)
- Vertical Bounce: Up-and-down motion, typically lowest frequency (5-15 Hz for typical isolation)
- Horizontal Translations (X and Y): Side-to-side motions, usually 1.5-2× vertical frequency
Rotational Modes (3)
- Roll: Rotation about longitudinal axis
- Pitch: Rotation about transverse axis
- Yaw: Rotation about vertical axis
- Frequencies: Typically 10-30 Hz, depend on equipment dimensions and center of gravity location
Coupled Modes
- If isolators not symmetric or CG not centered, modes couple
- Translation and rotation occur simultaneously
- Creates complex motion patterns
- More difficult to analyze and correct
When Mounting Resonance Occurs
Isolation System Resonance
The most common mounting resonance scenario:
- Design Intent: Isolators selected to have natural frequency at 1/3 to 1/5 of machine running speed
- Problem: If machine operates below design speed or passes through isolator frequency during startup
- Symptom: Severe vibration at speeds near isolator natural frequency
- Duration: Occurs only in specific speed range
Rail or Skid Resonance
- Mounting rails or equipment skids have own bending modes
- Typical frequencies: 15-50 Hz depending on span and stiffness
- Entire equipment assembly rocks on rails
- Common in modular equipment packages
Bracket or Support Resonance
- Wall-mounted or ceiling-mounted equipment on brackets
- Bracket or support arm has natural frequency
- Equipment motion amplified when frequency matches
- Can transmit vibration into building structure
Diagnostic Identification
Key Indicators
- Amplification: Vibration on mount >> vibration at equipment
- Rocking/Bouncing: Visible whole-machine motion
- Speed Sensitive: Severe only in narrow speed range
- Low Frequency: Typically 5-30 Hz range for isolated systems
- Phase Relationships: All mounting points move in-phase (bounce mode) or out-of-phase (rocking mode)
Diagnostic Procedure
- Identify Resonant Frequency: From vibration spectrum peak
- Impact Test Mounts: Bump test to determine mount natural frequency
- Compare: If resonant frequency ≈ mount natural frequency → mounting resonance confirmed
- Measure Multiple Locations: Check phase relationships between mount points
- Assess Mode Shape: Determine if bounce, rock, or coupled mode
Solutions
For Isolation System Resonance
Change Isolator Stiffness
- Stiffer Isolators: Raises natural frequency above operating speed
- Softer Isolators: Lowers frequency below startup range (if equipment can tolerate)
- Selection: Isolator frequency should be < 1/3 minimum operating speed
Add Damping
- Use isolators with built-in damping (elastomeric vs. steel spring)
- Add viscous dampers or friction dampers
- Reduces resonance peak amplitude even if frequency match remains
Improve Isolator Installation
- Ensure all isolators properly loaded (not cocked or binding)
- Verify isolators appropriate for actual equipment weight
- Check for seized or degraded isolators
- Ensure symmetric placement relative to center of gravity
For Structural Mounting Resonance
Stiffen Mounting Structure
- Add bracing to rails or skids
- Increase bracket thickness or add gussets
- Shorten unsupported spans
- Tie mounting points together
Change Mounting Configuration
- Add intermediate supports to reduce spans
- Relocate mounting points to stiffer locations
- Use more robust mounting hardware
Operational Solutions
- Speed Restriction: Avoid operating at resonant speeds
- Rapid Acceleration: Pass through resonance quickly during startup
- Reduce Excitation: Improve balance to minimize forcing at resonant frequency
Special Considerations
Vibration Isolation Design
Proper isolation system design prevents mounting resonance:
- Frequency Ratio: fisolator < 0.3 × fminimum operating
- Transmissibility: At resonance, transmissibility can be > 10 (amplification, not isolation)
- Operating Range: Ensure all operating frequencies > 2-3× isolator frequency for effective isolation
- Startup Consideration: Accept high vibration passing through resonance if brief
Coupled Equipment
Motor-driven equipment on common baseplate:
- Entire assembly has rigid-body modes on mounts
- Motor and driven equipment vibration couple through baseplate
- Resonance can be excited by either machine
- Requires treating as complete system, not individual machines
Measurement and Analysis Tools
Modal Analysis
- Complete characterization of all mounting system modes
- Identifies frequency, damping, and mode shape for each mode
- Provides data for design modifications
- Can be done experimentally or through FEA
Operating Deflection Shape (ODS)
- Visualize actual motion pattern during operation
- Distinguishes mounting resonance from rotor resonance
- Shows which mode is active (bounce, rock, etc.)
- Guides placement of stiffening modifications
Mounting resonance can create severe vibration even in well-maintained, properly balanced machinery. Understanding the natural frequencies of mounting systems, particularly vibration isolation systems, and ensuring adequate frequency separation from operating speeds is essential for successful vibration control in rotating equipment installations.