Understanding Rotor Instability

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,347.12 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,347.12.$1,901.46Trenutna cijena je: $1,901.46.

Parts

Vibration sensor

$106.96 Izvorna cijena bila je: $106.96.$71.30Trenutna cijena je: $71.30.

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$147.36 Izvorna cijena bila je: $147.36.$83.19Trenutna cijena je: $83.19.

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,084.78

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.67

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.88

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,061.90 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,061.90.$1,663.78Trenutna cijena je: $1,663.78.

Definition: What is Rotor Instability?

Rotor instability is a condition in rotating machinery where self-excited vibration develops and grows without bound (limited only by non-linear effects or system failure). Unlike vibration from unbalance or misalignment, which are forced vibrations responding to external forces, rotor instability is a self-sustaining oscillation where energy is continuously extracted from the steady rotational motion of the shaft and fed into the vibratory motion.

Rotor instability is one of the most dangerous conditions in rotor dynamics because it can occur suddenly, grow rapidly to destructive amplitudes, and cannot be corrected by balancing or alignment. It requires immediate shutdown and correction of the underlying destabilizing mechanism.

Fundamental Difference: Forced vs. Self-Excited Vibration

Forced Vibration (Stable)

Most common machinery vibration is forced:

• External force (unbalance, misalignment) drives the vibration
• Vibration amplitude proportional to forcing magnitude
• Frequency matches the forcing frequency (1X, 2X, etc.)
• Removing the force eliminates the vibration
• System is stable—vibration doesn’t grow without bound

Self-Excited Vibration (Unstable)

Rotor instability produces self-excited vibration:

• Energy is extracted from rotation itself, not external forces
• Amplitude grows exponentially once threshold speed is exceeded
• Frequency typically at or near a natural frequency (often sub-synchronous)
• Continues and grows even if unbalance is eliminated
• System is unstable—only shutdown or corrective action can stop it

Common Types of Rotor Instability

1. Oil Whirl

Oil whirl is the most common instability in fluid-film bearing systems:

• Mechanism: Oil wedge in bearing creates tangential force on shaft
• Frequency: Typically 0.42-0.48× running speed (sub-synchronous)
• Threshold: Occurs when speed exceeds approximately twice the first critical speed
• Symptom: High-amplitude sub-synchronous vibration that increases with speed
• Solution: Bearing design changes, preload, or offset configurations

2. Oil Whip (Severe Instability)

Oil whip is a severe form of oil whirl:

• Mechanism: Oil whirl locks onto a natural frequency
• Frequency: Locks at first natural frequency regardless of speed increases
• Threshold: Occurs at 2× first critical speed
• Symptom: Very high amplitude, constant frequency despite speed changes
• Danger: Can cause catastrophic bearing and shaft damage within minutes

3. Steam Whirl

Occurs in steam turbines with labyrinth seals:

• Mechanism: Aerodynamic cross-coupling forces in seal clearances
• Frequency: Sub-synchronous, near natural frequency
• Conditions: High-pressure differentials across seals
• Solution: Swirl brakes, anti-swirl devices, seal design modifications

4. Shaft Whip

General term for various self-excited instabilities:

• Can be caused by internal damping in the shaft material
• Dry friction whip from seals or rubs
• Aerodynamic or hydrodynamic cross-coupling forces

Characteristics and Symptoms

Vibration Signature

Rotor instability produces distinctive vibration patterns:

• Sub-Synchronous Frequency: Vibration frequency less than 1× running speed (typically 0.4-0.5×)
• Speed Independence: Once instability locks on, frequency stays constant even if speed changes
• Rapid Growth: Amplitude increases exponentially once threshold speed is exceeded
• High Amplitude: Can reach 2-10 times the amplitude of unbalance vibration
• Forward Precession: Shaft orbit rotates in same direction as shaft rotation

Onset Behavior

• Instability typically has a threshold speed
• Below threshold: system is stable, only forced vibration present
• At threshold: small disturbance triggers onset
• Above threshold: instability develops rapidly
• May be intermittent initially, then become continuous

Diagnostic Identification

Key Diagnostic Indicators

Distinguish instability from other vibration sources:

Characteristic	Unbalance (Forced)	Instability (Self-Excited)
Frequency	1× running speed	Sub-synchronous (often ~0.45×)
Amplitude vs. Speed	Increases smoothly with speed²	Sudden onset above threshold
Response to Balancing	Vibration reduced	No improvement
Frequency vs. Speed	Tracks with speed (constant order)	Constant frequency (changes order)
Shutdown Behavior	Reduces with speed	May persist briefly after speed drops

Confirming Instability

• Perform order analysis—instability shows as constant frequency, changing order
• Waterfall plot shows frequency not tracking with speed
• Balancing has no effect on subsynchronous component
• Orbit analysis shows forward precession at natural frequency

Prevention and Mitigation

Design Considerations

• Adequate Damping: Design bearing systems with sufficient damping to prevent instability
• Bearing Selection: Choose bearing types and configurations that provide good damping (tilting pad bearings, preloaded bearings)
• Stiffness Optimization: Proper shaft and bearing stiffness ratios
• Operating Speed Range: Design to operate below instability threshold speeds

Bearing Design Solutions

• Tilting Pad Bearings: Inherently stable bearing type for high-speed applications
• Pressure Dam Bearings: Modified geometry to increase effective damping
• Bearing Preload: Increases stiffness and damping, raises threshold speed
• Squeeze Film Dampers: External damping devices surrounding bearings

Operational Solutions

• Speed Restriction: Limit maximum speed to below threshold
• Load Increase: Higher bearing loads can improve stability margins
• Temperature Control: Bearing oil temperature affects viscosity and damping
• Continuous Monitoring: Early detection allows shutdown before damage occurs

Emergency Response

If rotor instability is detected during operation:

1. Immediate Action: Reduce speed or shut down immediately
2. Do Not Attempt Balancing: Balancing will not correct instability and wastes time
3. Document Conditions: Record speed at onset, frequency, amplitude progression
4. Investigate Root Cause: Identify which instability mechanism is present
5. Implement Correction: Modify bearings, seals, or operating conditions as needed
6. Verify Fix: Test carefully with close monitoring before returning to service

Stability Analysis

Engineers predict and prevent instability through stability analysis:

• Calculate eigenvalues of rotor-bearing system
• Real part of eigenvalue indicates stability (negative = stable, positive = unstable)
• Identify threshold speeds where stability changes
• Design modifications to ensure adequate stability margins
• Often requires specialized rotor dynamics software

Rotor instability, while less common than unbalance or misalignment, represents one of the most serious vibration conditions in rotating machinery. Understanding its mechanisms, recognizing its symptoms, and knowing appropriate corrective actions are essential skills for engineers and technicians working with high-speed rotating equipment.

---

← Back to Main Index