Understanding Electrical Unbalance
Definition: What is Electrical Unbalance?
Electrical unbalance (also called phase unbalance, voltage unbalance, or current unbalance) is a condition in three-phase electrical systems where the voltages or currents in the three phases are not equal in magnitude or are not separated by exactly 120 electrical degrees. This asymmetry in the electrical supply or motor windings creates unbalanced electromagnetic forces, excessive heating in motor windings, negative sequence currents, torque pulsations, and characteristic vibration at twice the line frequency.
Even small voltage imbalances (2-3%) can cause significant current imbalances (6-10×) and reduce motor efficiency and life. Electrical unbalance is a common problem in industrial facilities and can result from utility supply issues, poor power distribution, or motor winding defects.
Types of Electrical Unbalance
1. Voltage Unbalance
Unequal line-to-line or line-to-neutral voltages:
- Measurement: Measure voltage between each phase pair (AB, BC, CA)
- Calculation: % Voltage Unbalance = (Max deviation from average / average) × 100
- Example: Phases measure 477V, 480V, 483V → Average 480V, max deviation 3V → 0.625% unbalance
- Acceptable: < 1% per NEMA, < 2% per IEC
2. Current Unbalance
Unequal current in the three phases:
- Measurement: Measure current in each phase (IA, IB, IC)
- Calculation: % Current Unbalance = (Max deviation from average / average) × 100
- Causes: Voltage unbalance, winding faults, poor connections
- Amplification: Small voltage unbalance creates larger current unbalance (6-10× multiplier)
3. Phase Angle Unbalance
- Phases not separated by exactly 120°
- Creates pulsating torque and heating
- Less common than magnitude unbalance
- Requires power quality analyzer to detect
Causes of Electrical Unbalance
Utility Supply Issues
- Transformer Problems: Unbalanced distribution transformers
- Single-Phase Loads: Large single-phase loads on same supply creating asymmetry
- Transmission Line Issues: Unequal impedance in three phases
- Utility Fault Conditions: System disturbances
Facility Distribution
- Poor Connections: High resistance connections in one phase
- Blown Fuses: Partial loss of one phase (severe unbalance)
- Unequal Cable Lengths: Different impedances in phase conductors
- Single-Phasing: Complete loss of one phase (extreme unbalance)
Motor Internal Causes
- Winding Faults: Turn-to-turn shorts reducing effective turns in one phase
- Winding Asymmetry: Manufacturing variation in winding resistances
- Connection Problems: Poor terminal connections
- Damaged Windings: Partial short circuits or open circuits
Effects on Motor Performance
Overheating
The most serious consequence:
- Negative sequence currents create additional heating
- One phase carries more current than designed
- Temperature rise much greater than voltage unbalance would suggest
- Rule of Thumb: 3% voltage unbalance can cause 18-25% temperature rise
- Accelerated insulation aging and failure
Efficiency and Power Factor
- Lower efficiency from circulating currents
- Reduced power factor
- Increased energy consumption
- Typical efficiency loss: 1-2% for moderate unbalance
Torque Pulsations
- Pulsating torque at 2× line frequency
- Creates torsional vibration in drive train
- Can excite torsional resonances
- Reduces smooth operation
Vibration
- 2× Line Frequency: 120 Hz (60 Hz) or 100 Hz (50 Hz) vibration component
- Electromagnetic Origin: Pulsating magnetic forces
- Amplitude: Proportional to degree of unbalance
- Confusion: Can be mistaken for stator faults or magnetic pull
Reduced Service Life
- Increased thermal stress reduces insulation life
- Motor derating required (reduced capacity)
- 3% voltage unbalance can reduce motor life by 50%
Detection and Measurement
Voltage Measurement
- Measure line-to-line voltages (VAB, VBC, VCA) with motor running under load
- Calculate average and percent deviation
- Perform at motor terminals (not supply panel) to include voltage drop
- Document and trend over time
Current Measurement
- Measure current in each phase with clamp meter
- Calculate imbalance percentage
- Current unbalance often 6-10× voltage unbalance
- Increasing current imbalance indicates developing motor problem
Vibration Analysis
- Elevated 2× line frequency component
- Compare amplitude to baseline
- Distinguish from mechanical 2× (misalignment) by frequency (120/100 Hz vs. 2× running speed)
Thermal Monitoring
- Measure winding temperatures or motor frame temperature
- Temperature imbalance between phases
- Overall temperature higher than expected for load
Correction Methods
For Supply-Side Unbalance
- Contact utility if unbalance at service entrance
- Check and tighten all connections in distribution system
- Verify fuses and circuit breakers intact
- Balance single-phase loads across three phases
- Check transformer tap settings
For Motor-Side Issues
- Check and clean motor terminal connections
- Verify cable connections tight and clean
- Test for winding faults (insulation resistance, current signature analysis)
- Rewind or replace motor if internal fault confirmed
Derating
- If unbalance cannot be corrected, reduce motor loading
- NEMA recommends 1% derating per 1% voltage unbalance beyond 1%
- Monitor temperature closely
Prevention and Monitoring
Installation
- Verify voltage balance at motor terminals before energizing
- Use properly sized conductors (minimize voltage drop)
- Ensure all connections clean and tight
- Verify correct motor connection (wye vs. delta)
Operation
- Periodic voltage and current measurement
- Trending to detect developing problems
- Monitor for blown fuses or tripped breakers
- Power quality surveys in facilities with recurring motor problems
Electrical unbalance is a common but often overlooked motor problem that significantly impacts motor health, efficiency, and longevity. Understanding the relationship between voltage unbalance and current imbalance, recognizing the 2× line frequency vibration signature, and maintaining balanced electrical supply through proper installation and monitoring are essential for optimal motor performance and reliability.
EN 
AR 
AZ 
BG 
ZH 
HR 
CS 
DA 
NL 
ET 
FI 
FR 
DE 
KA 
EL 
HE 
HI 
HU 
ID 
IT 
JA 
KO 
LV 
LT 
MS 
NB 
FA 
PL 
PT_BR 
PT 
RO 
SR 
SK 
SL 
ES 
SV 
TH 
TR 
UR 
UK 
VI 