Understanding Interference Diagrams
Definition: What is an Interference Diagram?
An interference diagram is a graphical tool used in rotor dynamics to identify rotational speed ranges where excitation frequencies “interfere” with (match) the system’s natural frequencies, creating conditions for resonance. The term “interference” refers to the problematic interaction between an forcing frequency (from unbalance, blade passing, or other sources) and a natural frequency that can cause excessive vibration.
While closely related to the Campbell diagram, an interference diagram often focuses specifically on highlighting the intersection points (interferences) and associated speed zones that should be avoided or passed through quickly during operation.
Relationship to Campbell Diagrams
In practice, the terms “interference diagram” and “Campbell diagram” are often used interchangeably, as they display similar information. However, subtle distinctions exist:
Campbell Diagram Emphasis
- Shows the complete picture of how natural frequencies vary with speed
- Displays natural frequency curves as continuous functions of speed
- Used primarily for comprehensive rotor dynamic analysis and design
Interference Diagram Emphasis
- Focuses attention on the specific problem areas—the intersection points
- Often includes shaded “forbidden zones” around critical speeds
- More operational in focus, emphasizing speed ranges to avoid
- May include multiple excitation sources beyond just unbalance
Construction of an Interference Diagram
An interference diagram is constructed similarly to a Campbell diagram but with additional operational context:
Basic Elements
- Horizontal Axis: Rotational speed (RPM or Hz)
- Vertical Axis: Excitation or natural frequency (Hz or CPM)
- Natural Frequency Lines: Showing how system natural frequencies change with speed
- Excitation Order Lines: Diagonal lines for 1X, 2X, 3X, and other excitation sources
Additional Features
- Intersection Points Highlighted: Critical speeds clearly marked with symbols or annotations
- Forbidden Speed Zones: Shaded bands around each critical speed showing ranges to avoid
- Operating Speed Range: Clearly indicated, often as a vertical band or highlighted region
- Rapid Traverse Zones: Speed ranges to pass through quickly during startup/shutdown
- Multiple Excitation Sources: Lines for blade passing frequency, gear mesh frequency, bearing defect frequencies
Types of Interferences
An interference diagram can identify various types of problematic interactions:
1. Synchronous Interference (1X)
The most common type, where once-per-revolution unbalance forces coincide with a natural frequency. This is the classic critical speed condition.
2. Harmonic Interference (2X, 3X, etc.)
Higher harmonics of the running speed can also excite resonances. Common sources include:
- 2X: From misalignment, mechanical looseness, or asymmetric stiffness
- 3X, 4X: From gear tooth contacts, multi-lobe bearings, or structural asymmetries
3. Blade/Vane Passing Interference
For turbomachinery, the blade passing frequency (number of blades × RPM) can excite structural modes. The interference diagram shows where blade passing frequency lines cross natural frequencies.
4. Sub-Synchronous Interference
Phenomena like oil whirl (typically at 0.43X-0.48X) can create sub-synchronous interferences that must be identified and managed.
5. Beat Frequency Interference
In coupled systems or systems with multiple rotating elements, beat frequencies from slight speed differences can create interferences.
Practical Use in Machine Design
Design Phase Applications
- Critical Speed Avoidance: Ensure operating speed range doesn’t overlap with interference zones
- Separation Margin Verification: Confirm adequate margins (typically ±15% to ±30%) around all critical speeds
- Excitation Source Management: If an interference cannot be avoided, reduce the amplitude of the excitation source (improve balance, reduce misalignment, etc.)
- Damping Requirements: Identify where enhanced damping is needed to control resonant vibration
Modification and Troubleshooting
When existing machinery experiences vibration problems, interference diagrams help:
- Identify if the problem is due to operating too close to a critical speed
- Evaluate proposed modifications (bearing changes, added mass, stiffness modifications)
- Predict effects of speed changes or variable speed operation
- Determine if the issue is from an unexpected excitation source
Establishing Forbidden Speed Zones
A key feature of interference diagrams is defining forbidden or restricted speed zones:
Zone Width Determination
The width of each forbidden zone depends on several factors:
- System Damping: Low damping requires wider zones; high damping allows narrower zones
- Excitation Amplitude: Strong excitation sources require wider avoidance zones
- Operational Consequences: Critical equipment may require more conservative (wider) zones
- Typical Values: ±15% for well-damped systems, ±20-30% for poorly damped systems
Operating Procedures
Based on the interference diagram, operating procedures are established:
- Continuous Operation Permitted: Speed ranges with no interferences
- Rapid Traverse Required: Forbidden zones that must be passed through quickly during startup/shutdown
- Absolutely Prohibited: Severe resonance zones where operation is never permitted
Example: Turbine Interference Diagram
Consider a steam turbine with the following characteristics:
- Operating Speed: 3000 RPM (50 Hz)
- First Critical Speed: 2400 RPM (40 Hz)
- Second Critical Speed: 4200 RPM (70 Hz)
- Number of Blades: 60
- Blade Passing Frequency at 3000 RPM: 60 × 50 Hz = 3000 Hz
Interference Diagram Shows:
- 1X Line crosses first natural frequency: Critical speed at 2400 RPM—Forbidden zone: 2040-2760 RPM (±15%)
- 1X Line crosses second natural frequency: Critical speed at 4200 RPM—Not a concern as operating speed is well below
- Operating Speed (3000 RPM): Safely between two critical speeds with good separation margins
- Blade Passing Frequency: At 3000 Hz, no interference with structural modes in the operating range
Operational Guidance:
- During startup, accelerate through 2040-2760 RPM range in less than 30 seconds
- Continuous operation between 2800-3200 RPM is acceptable
- Do not attempt to operate continuously between 2040-2760 RPM
Advanced Considerations
Temperature Effects
Some interference diagrams include multiple curves showing how natural frequencies shift with temperature changes (thermal growth affects stiffness and bearing characteristics). Critical speeds can move as the machine warms up.
Load Effects
For machinery where process load significantly affects bearing stiffness or rotor deflection, interference diagrams may show families of curves for different load conditions.
Coupled Systems
When multiple rotors are coupled (motor-pump sets, turbine-generator sets), the interference diagram must account for coupled torsional and lateral modes that can create additional critical speeds.
Creating an Interference Diagram
From Analytical Models
- Develop finite element model of rotor-bearing system
- Calculate natural frequencies at multiple speeds
- Plot natural frequency curves vs. speed
- Overlay excitation order lines (1X, 2X, blade passing, etc.)
- Mark intersection points and establish forbidden zones
- Annotate with operating speed range and procedures
From Experimental Data
- Perform startup and coastdown tests with vibration monitoring
- Generate waterfall plots or Bode plots
- Identify critical speed locations from amplitude peaks and phase shifts
- Create interference diagram marking observed critical speeds
- Establish empirical forbidden zones based on measured vibration levels
Benefits for Operations and Maintenance
Interference diagrams provide valuable guidance for machine operators and maintenance personnel:
- Clear Operating Limits: Visual indication of safe and unsafe speed ranges
- Startup/Shutdown Procedures: Identifies speeds to traverse quickly
- Variable Speed Operation: Defines acceptable speed ranges for adjustable speed drives
- Troubleshooting Tool: Helps diagnose if vibration problems are speed-related
- Modification Planning: Shows impact of proposed changes before implementation
- Training Aid: Educational tool for understanding machine dynamic behavior
For critical rotating machinery, the interference diagram is an essential document that should be available to operators, maintenance technicians, and engineering staff, ensuring everyone understands the machine’s dynamic characteristics and operates it within safe speed ranges.
EN 
AR 
AZ 
BG 
ZH 
HR 
CS 
DA 
NL 
ET 
FI 
FR 
DE 
KA 
EL 
HE 
HI 
HU 
ID 
IT 
JA 
KO 
LV 
LT 
MS 
NB 
FA 
PL 
PT_BR 
PT 
RO 
SR 
SK 
SL 
ES 
SV 
TH 
TR 
UR 
UK 
VI 