What is a Shaft Crack? Detection and Diagnosis • Portable balancer, vibration analyzer "Balanset" for dynamic balancing crushers, fans, mulchers, augers on combines, shafts, centrifuges, turbines, and many others rotors What is a Shaft Crack? Detection and Diagnosis • Portable balancer, vibration analyzer "Balanset" for dynamic balancing crushers, fans, mulchers, augers on combines, shafts, centrifuges, turbines, and many others rotors

What is a Shaft Crack? Detection and Diagnosis

Published by admin on

Understanding Shaft Cracks in Rotating Machinery

Definition: What is a Shaft Crack?

A shaft crack is a fracture or discontinuity in a rotating shaft that develops from fatigue, stress concentration, or material defects. Cracks typically initiate at the surface and propagate inward perpendicular to the direction of maximum tensile stress. In rotating machinery, shaft cracks are extremely dangerous because they can progress from a small, undetectable flaw to complete shaft fracture in a matter of hours or days, potentially causing catastrophic equipment failure.

Shaft cracks produce distinctive vibration signatures, particularly a characteristic 2× (twice per revolution) component that appears as the crack develops. Early detection through vibration analysis is critical to prevent complete shaft failure and associated safety hazards.

Common Causes of Shaft Cracks

1. Fatigue from Cyclic Stresses

The most common cause, particularly in rotating machinery:

  • Bending Fatigue: Rotating shaft with uneven stiffness or loads creates cyclic bending stress
  • Torsional Fatigue: Oscillating torque in power transmission shafts
  • High-Cycle Fatigue: Millions of stress cycles accumulate over years of operation
  • Stress Concentration: Keyways, holes, fillets, and geometric discontinuities concentrate stress

2. Operating Conditions

  • Excessive Unbalance: High centrifugal forces create bending stress
  • Misalignment: Bending moments from misalignment accelerate fatigue
  • Resonance Operation: Operating at or near critical speeds creates high deflections
  • Overload: Operating beyond design limits
  • Thermal Stress: Rapid heating/cooling cycles or thermal gradients

3. Material and Manufacturing Defects

  • Material Inclusions: Slag, voids, or foreign material in shaft material
  • Improper Heat Treatment: Inadequate hardening or tempering
  • Machining Defects: Tool marks, gouges, or scratches creating stress risers
  • Corrosion Pitting: Surface corrosion creating crack initiation sites
  • Fretting: At press-fit interfaces or keyways

4. Operational Events

  • Overspeed Events: Emergency or accidental overspeed creating high stresses
  • Severe Rubs: Contact generating heat and local stress concentration
  • Impact Loading: Sudden loads from process upsets or mechanical shocks
  • Previous Repairs: Welding or machining introducing residual stresses

Vibration Symptoms of a Cracked Shaft

The Characteristic 2× Component

The hallmark vibration signature of a cracked shaft is a prominent 2× (second harmonic) component:

Why 2× Vibration Develops

  • A crack opens and closes twice per revolution as the shaft rotates
  • When crack is in compression (bottom of rotation), stiffness is higher
  • When crack is in tension (top of rotation), crack opens, stiffness is lower
  • This twice-per-revolution stiffness change creates 2× forcing
  • 2× amplitude increases as crack propagates and stiffness asymmetry grows

Additional Vibration Indicators

  • 1× Changes: Gradual increase in 1× vibration from changed stiffness and residual bow
  • Higher Harmonics: 3×, 4× may appear as crack severity increases
  • Phase Shifts: Phase angle changes during startup/coastdown or at different speeds
  • Speed-Dependent Behavior: Vibration may change non-linearly with speed
  • Temperature Sensitivity: Vibration may correlate with thermal expansion opening/closing crack

Startup/Coastdown Characteristics

  • 2× component shows unusual behavior during transients
  • May show two peaks in Bode plot (at 1/2 of each critical speed)
  • Phase changes of 1× component may differ from normal unbalance response

Detection Methods

Vibration Monitoring

Trending Analysis

  • Monitor 2X/1X ratio over time
  • Gradual increase in 2× amplitude is warning sign
  • 2X/1X ratio > 0.5 warrants investigation
  • Sudden changes in vibration pattern suspicious

Spectral Analysis

  • Regular FFT analysis showing harmonics
  • Compare current to historical baseline spectra
  • Watch for emergence or growth of 2× peak

Transient Analysis

  • Waterfall plots during startup/coastdown
  • Bode plots showing amplitude and phase vs. speed
  • Unusual behavior at critical speed passages

Non-Vibration Methods

1. Magnetic Particle Inspection (MPI)

  • Detects surface and near-surface cracks
  • Requires accessible shaft surface
  • High reliability for crack detection
  • Part of routine maintenance inspections

2. Ultrasonic Testing (UT)

  • Detects internal and surface cracks
  • Can find cracks before they produce vibration symptoms
  • Requires specialist equipment and trained personnel
  • Recommended for critical shafts

3. Dye Penetrant Inspection

  • Simple method for surface crack detection
  • Requires cleaning and surface preparation
  • Useful for accessible areas during outages

4. Eddy Current Testing

  • Non-contact surface crack detection
  • Good for automated inspection
  • Effective on non-magnetic and magnetic materials

Response and Corrective Actions

Immediate Actions Upon Detection

  1. Increase Monitoring Frequency: From monthly to weekly or daily
  2. Reduce Operating Severity: Lower speed or load if possible
  3. Plan Shutdown: Schedule repair or replacement at earliest safe opportunity
  4. Perform NDE: Confirm crack presence and assess severity
  5. Risk Assessment: Determine if continued operation is safe

Long-Term Solutions

  • Shaft Replacement: Most reliable solution for confirmed cracks
  • Repair (Limited Cases): Some cracks can be removed by machining and building up with weld (requires expert evaluation)
  • Root Cause Analysis: Identify why crack developed to prevent recurrence
  • Design Modifications: Address stress concentrations, improve material selection, modify operating conditions

Prevention Strategies

Design Phase

  • Eliminate sharp corners and stress concentrations
  • Use generous fillet radii at diameter changes
  • Specify appropriate materials for stress levels and environment
  • Perform finite element stress analysis
  • Apply surface treatments (shot peening, nitriding) to improve fatigue resistance

Operational Phase

  • Maintain good balance quality to minimize cyclic bending stress
  • Ensure precision alignment
  • Avoid operation at critical speeds
  • Prevent overspeed events
  • Control thermal stresses through proper warm-up/cooldown

Maintenance Phase

  • Regular inspections using appropriate NDE methods
  • Vibration trending programs to detect early symptoms
  • Periodic balancing to minimize fatigue stresses
  • Corrosion prevention and coating maintenance

Shaft cracks represent one of the most serious potential failures in rotating machinery. The combination of vibration monitoring (to detect characteristic 2× signatures) and periodic non-destructive examination provides the best strategy for early crack detection, allowing planned maintenance before catastrophic failure occurs.

← Back to Main Index

Categories:
WhatsApp