Understanding Brush Defects

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

€1,975.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Vibration sensor

€90.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

€124.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Devices

Balanset-4

€6,803.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

€46.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Reflective tape

€10.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

€1,735.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Brush defects are problems in the carbon or metal-graphite brushes that conduct electrical current between the stationary and rotating parts of DC motors, wound-rotor AC motors, generators and slip-ring assemblies. The common defects are brush wear, improper seating, chattering (bouncing), sparking, contamination and spring-tension problems. Each one creates trouble on more than one front: electrical (poor current transfer and arcing), mechanical (vibration from bouncing), and — if left uncorrected — secondary damage to the commutator or slip rings.

Brush-type machines are gradually being displaced by AC induction motors, but they are far from extinct. DC drives, wound-rotor motors, generators and a range of specialty equipment still rely on brushes, so recognising brush defects remains a core part of electric-motor diagnostics and of any electrical fault investigation on rotating plant.

1. Common Brush Defects

Brush Wear

Some wear is normal, but it can be badly accelerated:

• Normal wear: gradual material loss from friction — on the order of 1–2 mm per 1000 hours.
• Accelerated wear: driven by high current, poor lubrication (no protective carbon film), or contamination.
• Symptoms: brushes visibly shortened and approaching their minimum length.
• Consequences: weak spring pressure as the brush shortens, leading to poor contact and increased sparking.
• Action: replace when worn to the minimum length, typically one-third to one-half of the original.

Brush Chattering (Bouncing)

Here the brush intermittently loses contact with the commutator:

• Causes: inadequate spring pressure, a rough commutator, external vibration, or an eccentric commutator.
• Symptoms: visible sparking, audible buzzing or rattling, and electrical noise.
• Vibration: the bouncing creates impacts at the commutator bar-pass frequency.
• Damage: accelerates commutator wear and inflicts arcing damage.
• Frequency: chattering typically lives in the 100–1000 Hz range.

Poor Brush Seating

• Description: the brush face does not conform to the curvature of the commutator.
• Causes: new brushes that have not been run in, improper installation, or too hard a brush grade.
• Effect: reduced contact area, high local current density, and concentrated heating.
• Symptoms: excessive sparking, hot spots and rapid wear.
• Solution: a proper run-in procedure, correct brush-grade selection, and seating stones.

Contamination

• Oil and grease: reduce friction, prevent the carbon film from forming, and cause electrical tracking.
• Dust: abrasive particles that accelerate wear.
• Moisture: promotes corrosion and disturbs the electrical contact.
• Carbon-dust build-up: can short between segments or create tracking paths.

Brush Spring Issues

• Weak springs: insufficient pressure, poor contact and bouncing.
• Broken springs: no pressure at all, so the brush stops contacting.
• Incorrect pressure: too high causes excessive wear, too low causes poor contact.
• Corrosion: corroded springs lose their elasticity.

Sparking and Arcing

• Visible sparks at the brush-to-commutator interface.
• Causes include chattering, poor contact, overload and commutator damage.
• The damage is progressive, pitting the commutator surface.
• In the worst case it leads to a flashover — an arc bridging multiple segments.

2. Vibration Signatures

Brush-Related Vibration

• Chattering: high-frequency vibration in the 100–1000 Hz band as the brush bounces.
• Commutator bar frequency: number of commutator bars × RPM / 60.
• Electrical harmonics: a family of harmonics from arcing and the repeated interruption of current.
• Broadband noise: random high-frequency content generated by sparking.
• Amplitude modulation: appears if eccentricity makes the contact pressure vary once per revolution.

Secondary Mechanical Effects

• Brush friction creates tangential forces on the commutator.
• Uneven brush wear can produce unbalance-like symptoms.
• Asymmetric spring pressure can disturb the rotor’s centring.

Because several of these signatures overlap in frequency with genuine mechanical faults, brush problems are a classic source of diagnostic confusion — a reminder always to confirm the commutator bar-pass frequency before blaming the bearings.

3. Detection Methods

Visual Inspection

• Brush length: measure the remaining length and replace below the minimum.
• Contact surface: it should be smooth and conformal to the commutator.
• Sparking: observe in a darkened area — light sparking is normal, heavy sparking is a problem.
• Contamination: check for oil, dust and carbon build-up.
• Spring condition: verify the springs are intact and delivering the correct tension.

Electrical Tests

• Brush contact resistance: should be low and consistent across all brushes.
• Spring pressure: measure with a spring scale — typically 1.5–3.5 psi of contact pressure.
• Voltage drop: across the brush-to-commutator interface, normally less than 1 V per brush.

Vibration and Acoustic Methods

• High-frequency accelerometer measurements to capture the impacts of chattering.
• Acoustic emission for detecting arcing.
• Ultrasonic monitoring for corona discharge or tracking.
• Spectrum analysis to isolate the commutator bar frequency.

Thermal Imaging

• Hot brushes indicate poor contact or overload.
• Hot spots on the commutator point to localised problems.
• Thermography can reveal a temperature imbalance between brush sets.

4. Measuring Brush Vibration in the Field

When a brush-type machine is suspected of chattering or arcing, the practical test is a high-frequency vibration measurement at the brush-gear housing. A portable two-channel analyser such as the Balanset-1A lets you capture the spectrum and confirm whether the energy lines up with the commutator bar-pass frequency or with a broadband sparking pattern. Used alongside a visual check in a darkened enclosure and a voltage-drop test, it helps separate a true brush defect from an unrelated bearing or balance issue — and, once new brushes are seated, verifies that the high-frequency content has dropped back to baseline. Tracking those readings within a condition-monitoring programme turns a reactive replacement into a planned one.

5. Maintenance and Correction

Routine Brush Maintenance

• Inspection frequency: monthly for critical machines, quarterly for general applications — a natural fit for route-based periodic monitoring.
• Cleaning: vacuum away carbon dust and clean the commutator surface.
• Length check: replace brushes once they reach the minimum length.
• Spring tension: verify the correct pressure.
• Commutator condition: check for scoring, pitting and high bars.

Brush Replacement

• Use the correct grade for the application — consult the manufacturer.
• Replace all brushes in a set together.
• Ensure a proper fit in the brush holders.
• Allow new brushes a run-in period of 24–48 hours to seat fully.
• Verify the spring pressure again after installation.

Commutator Maintenance

• Clean regularly with approved solvents or stones.
• Turn (machine) the commutator if it becomes grooved or rough.
• Undercut the mica between bars where specified.
• Check for high bars, loose bars and damaged segments.

6. Prevention Best Practices

Operating Practices

• Operate within the rated current to limit brush heating.
• Avoid excessive starting frequency — starting current stresses the brushes.
• Keep the environment clean to prevent contamination.
• Control humidity; air that is too dry or too wet both degrade the contact.

Selection and Design

• Specify an appropriate brush grade — soft or hard — for the current density.
• Provide an adequate number of brushes for the current.
• Use a proper brush-holder design.
• Consider brushless alternatives for new installations.

Brush defects, though specific to DC and wound-rotor machinery, are important maintenance items that reward regular inspection and timely replacement. A clear grasp of the wear mechanisms, sound maintenance practice, and recognition of the diagnostic symptoms keeps brush-type motors running reliably — and prevents the electrical and mechanical damage that follows neglected brushes.

---

← Back to Main Index