Understanding Hydraulic Forces in Pumps
Definition: What are Hydraulic Forces?
Hydraulic forces are forces exerted on pump components by the flowing liquid, including pressure-induced loads on impeller vanes, axial thrust from pressure differentials, radial forces from asymmetric pressure distributions, and pulsating forces from flow turbulence and vane-volute interaction. These forces are distinct from mechanical forces (from unbalance, misalignment) in that they arise from fluid pressure and momentum changes, creating vibration components at vane passing frequency and related harmonics.
Understanding hydraulic forces is essential for pump reliability because these forces create bearing loads, shaft deflection, and vibration that vary with operating conditions (flow rate, pressure, fluid properties), making pump behavior different from other rotating machinery where forces are primarily mechanical.
Types of Hydraulic Forces
1. Axial Thrust (Hydraulic Thrust)
Net axial force from pressure differential across impeller:
- Mechanism: Discharge pressure on one side, suction pressure on other side of impeller
- Direction: Usually toward suction (back of impeller)
- Magnitude: Can be thousands of pounds even in moderate pumps
- Effect: Loads thrust bearing, can cause axial vibration
- Varies With: Flow rate, pressure, impeller design
Thrust Balancing Methods
- Balance Holes: Holes in impeller shroud equalizing pressure
- Back Vanes: Vanes on back side pumping fluid to reduce pressure
- Double-Suction Impellers: Symmetric design canceling thrust
- Opposed Impellers: Multi-stage pumps with impellers facing opposite directions
2. Radial Forces
Sideways forces from asymmetric pressure distribution:
At Best Efficiency Point (BEP)
- Pressure distribution relatively symmetric around impeller
- Radial forces balanced and cancel
- Minimal net radial force
- Lowest vibration condition
Off BEP (Low Flow)
- Asymmetric pressure distribution in volute
- Net radial force toward volute tongue
- Force magnitude increases as flow decreases
- Can be 20-40% of impeller weight at shutoff
- Creates 1× vibration from rotating radial force
Off BEP (High Flow)
- Different asymmetry pattern
- Radial force present but typically less than at low flow
- Flow turbulence adds random force components
3. Vane Passing Pulsations
Periodic pressure pulses as vanes pass cutwater:
- Frequency: Number of vanes × RPM / 60
- Mechanism: Each vane passing creates pressure pulse
- Forces: Act on impeller, volute, and casing
- Vibration: Dominant at vane passing frequency
- Magnitude: Depends on clearance, operating point, design
4. Recirculation Forces
- Low-frequency unsteady forces from flow instabilities
- Occur at very low or very high flow rates
- Frequencies typically 0.2-0.8× running speed
- Can create severe low-frequency vibration
- Indicates operation far from BEP
Effects on Pump Performance
Bearing Loading
- Hydraulic radial forces add to mechanical loads
- Varying forces create cyclic loading
- Maximum loading at low flow conditions
- Bearing selection must account for hydraulic loads
- Bearing life reduced by hydraulic forces (Life ∝ 1/Load³)
Shaft Deflection
- Radial forces deflect shaft
- Changes seal clearances and wear rings
- Can affect efficiency
- Extreme cases lead to rubs
Vibration Generation
- 1× Component: From steady or slowly-varying radial force
- VPF Component: From pressure pulsations
- Low-Frequency: From recirculation and instabilities
- Operating Point Dependent: Vibration varies with flow rate
Mechanical Stress
- Cyclic forces create fatigue loading
- Impeller vanes stressed by pressure differentials
- Shaft fatig from bending moments
- Casing stress from pressure pulsations
Hydraulic Force Minimization
Operate Near BEP
- Most effective strategy for minimizing hydraulic forces
- Operate within 80-110% of BEP flow when possible
- Radial forces minimum at BEP
- Vibration and bearing loads minimized
Design Features
- Diffuser Pumps: More symmetric pressure distribution than volute
- Double Volute: Two cutwaters 180° apart balance radial forces
- Increased Clearances: Reduce vane passing pressure pulsations (but lower efficiency)
- Vane Number Selection: Optimize to avoid acoustic resonances
System Design
- Minimum flow recirculation for baseload pumps
- Properly sized pump for actual duty (avoid oversizing)
- Variable speed drive to maintain optimal operating point
- Inlet design minimizing pre-swirl and turbulence
Diagnostic Use
Performance Curves and Hydraulic Forces
- Plot vibration vs. flow rate
- Minimum vibration typically at or near BEP
- Increasing vibration at low flow indicates high radial forces
- Guides operating range selection
VPF Analysis
- VPF amplitude indicates hydraulic pulsation severity
- Increasing VPF suggests clearance degradation or operating point shift
- VPF harmonics indicate turbulent, disturbed flow
Measurement Considerations
Vibration Measurement Locations
- Bearing Housings: Detect overall mechanical and hydraulic forces
- Pump Casing: More sensitive to hydraulic pulsations
- Suction and Discharge Piping: Pressure pulsation transmission
- Multiple Locations: Distinguish hydraulic from mechanical sources
Pressure Pulsation Measurement
- Pressure transducers in suction and discharge
- Directly measure hydraulic pulsations
- Correlate with vibration
- Identify acoustic resonances
Hydraulic forces are fundamental to pump operation and a major source of pump vibration and loading. Understanding how these forces vary with operating conditions, recognizing their signatures in vibration spectra, and designing/operating pumps to minimize hydraulic forces through near-BEP operation are essential for achieving reliable, long-life pump performance in industrial applications.
EN 
AR 
AZ 
BG 
ZH 
HR 
CS 
DA 
NL 
ET 
FI 
FR 
DE 
KA 
EL 
HE 
HI 
HU 
ID 
IT 
JA 
KO 
LV 
LT 
MS 
NB 
FA 
PL 
PT_BR 
PT 
RO 
SR 
SK 
SL 
ES 
SV 
TH 
TR 
UR 
UK 
VI 