Understanding Permanent Calibration in Rotor Balancing

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

Complete vibration diagnostics and balancing kit from Vibromera, including four vibration sensors with cables, a signal interface module, laser tachometer with magnetic stand, digital scale, USB cable, and a carrying case. The system is designed for field rotor balancing and condition monitoring on industrial equipment.

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

Definition: What is Permanent Calibration?

Permanent calibration (also called stored calibration or saved influence coefficients) is a technique in field balancing where the influence coefficients determined during an initial balancing procedure are saved and reused for subsequent balancing operations on the same machine or on identical machines. This eliminates the need for trial weight runs in future balancing sessions, significantly reducing the time and effort required.

The technique is based on the principle that for a given rotor-bearing-support system, the influence coefficients—which describe how the system responds to unbalance—remain essentially constant over time, assuming the mechanical characteristics of the system don’t change significantly.

How Permanent Calibration Works

The permanent calibration procedure involves two distinct phases:

Phase 1: Initial Calibration (One-Time Setup)

During the first balancing of a machine, a complete influence coefficient method procedure is performed:

Initial Run: Measure the initial unbalance condition.
Trial Weight Runs: Perform one or more trial weight runs (depending on whether it’s single-plane or two-plane balancing).
Calculate Influence Coefficients: The balancing instrument calculates the influence coefficients from the trial weight data.
Store Coefficients: The calculated influence coefficients are saved in the instrument’s memory, associated with a specific machine identifier.
Complete Balancing: Correction weights are calculated, installed, and verified as normal.

Phase 2: Subsequent Balancing (Using Stored Calibration)

For future balancing operations on the same machine:

Recall Stored Coefficients: Load the previously saved influence coefficients for this machine.
Single Measurement Run: Measure only the current unbalance vibration (amplitude and phase).
Direct Calculation: Using the stored coefficients, the instrument immediately calculates the required correction weights without any trial runs.
Install and Verify: Install the calculated corrections and verify the results.

This reduces a typical two-plane balancing procedure from five machine runs (initial, trial #1, trial #2, correction, verification) to just two runs (initial measurement, verification)—a significant time savings.

Benefits of Permanent Calibration

Permanent calibration offers compelling advantages, particularly in specific operational contexts:

1. Significant Time Savings

Eliminating trial weight runs can reduce balancing time by 50-70%. For critical production equipment where downtime is expensive, this translates directly to cost savings.

2. Reduced Machine Cycles

Fewer starts and stops extend the life of equipment, particularly for machines with limited start-cycle ratings or high thermal stresses during startup.

3. Simplified Procedure

Technicians don’t need to handle, weigh, and install trial weights, reducing complexity and potential for errors.

4. Consistency

Using the same calibration data ensures consistent balancing approach across multiple operators and service sessions.

5. Production Line Efficiency

For manufacturers balancing identical rotors in production (e.g., motor rotors, fan impellers), permanent calibration dramatically speeds up the process, making in-line or end-of-line balancing practical.

When to Use Permanent Calibration

Permanent calibration is most beneficial in specific scenarios:

Ideal Applications

Routine Rebalancing: Equipment that requires periodic rebalancing due to buildup, wear, or operational changes.
Fleet of Identical Machines: Multiple identical units (same model, mounting, operating conditions) where calibration from one can be applied to others.
Production Balancing: Manufacturing environments balancing many identical rotors.
Minimal Downtime Requirements: Critical equipment where every minute of downtime has high economic impact.
Stable Mechanical Systems: Machines with consistent bearing characteristics, rigid foundations, and unchanging operating conditions.

When Not to Use

Permanent calibration may not be appropriate when:

Significant mechanical changes have occurred (bearing replacement, foundation modifications, coupling changes)
Operating speed has changed from the calibration speed
The rotor has undergone structural modifications
System behavior has become non-linear (looseness, cracks, bearing wear)
It’s a unique, one-time balancing job
High-precision balance quality is required (trial runs provide verification)

Validity and Limitations

The effectiveness of permanent calibration depends on several assumptions and limitations:

Assumptions That Must Hold

System Linearity: The rotor-bearing system must respond linearly to unbalance (vibration response is proportional to unbalance mass).
Mechanical Stability: Bearing stiffness, damping, and foundation characteristics must remain essentially unchanged.
Operating Conditions: Speed, temperature, load, and other factors affecting vibration response must be consistent.
Correction Plane Radius: Weights must be placed at the same radial location as during calibration.

Sources of Error

Several factors can cause stored calibrations to become inaccurate over time:

Bearing wear increasing clearances and changing stiffness
Foundation settling or degradation
Changes in mounting bolt torque
Temperature variations affecting bearing characteristics
Process condition changes (flow, pressure, load)

Best Practices for Permanent Calibration

To ensure reliable results when using permanent calibration:

1. Perform High-Quality Initial Calibration

Use appropriate trial weight sizes (producing 25-50% vibration change)
Ensure good signal-to-noise ratio during measurements
Take multiple measurements and average them
Verify the calibration produces acceptable results in the initial balancing

2. Document Everything

Record critical information with the stored calibration:

Machine identification and location
Date of calibration
Operating conditions (speed, temperature, load)
Measurement locations and sensor types
Correction plane locations and radii
Any special conditions or considerations

3. Verify Periodically

Periodically perform a full trial weight procedure to verify that stored coefficients remain valid. A good practice is to:

Perform trial weight verification annually
Re-verify after any significant mechanical work
Compare actual vs. predicted results when using stored calibration

4. Set Validation Limits

Establish criteria for when to recalibrate:

If calculated correction weights are unreasonably large
If vibration doesn’t reduce as expected after correction
If vibration has changed significantly from typical patterns

5. Use Verification Runs

Always perform a verification run after installing corrections calculated from stored calibration. If results are unsatisfactory, perform a fresh calibration with trial weights.

Permanent Calibration in Production Environments

In manufacturing settings, permanent calibration is particularly valuable:

Setup Procedure

Balance a “master” rotor using the full trial weight procedure on the production balancing station.
Store the influence coefficients as the standard for this rotor type.
For each subsequent rotor, measure initial unbalance and apply corrections calculated using stored coefficients.
Track success rate and periodically verify calibration accuracy using trial weights on sample rotors.

Quality Control

Implement statistical process control to monitor:

Distribution of initial unbalance values
Distribution of correction weight sizes and angles
Residual unbalance after correction
Frequency of correction failures requiring rework

Technology and Software Support

Modern balancing instruments provide extensive permanent calibration features:

Database Storage: Store multiple calibrations organized by machine ID, model, or location
Coefficient Management: Edit, update, and delete stored calibrations
Validity Indicators: Track calibration date, usage count, and success statistics
Export/Import: Share calibration data across instruments or backup to computer
Automatic Mode Selection: Select between trial weight mode and permanent calibration mode

Relationship to Other Balancing Concepts

Permanent calibration builds upon fundamental balancing principles:

It relies on the accuracy of the influence coefficient method
Success depends on good balancing sensitivity
Results must meet balancing tolerance requirements
It’s compatible with both single-plane and two-plane balancing procedures

Understanding these foundational concepts is essential for successfully implementing and troubleshooting permanent calibration techniques.

← Back to Main Index

What is Permanent Calibration in Rotor Balancing?

Published by admin on October 31, 2025 October 31, 2025