What is Synchronous Averaging? Signal Enhancement • Portable balancer, vibration analyzer "Balanset" for dynamic balancing crushers, fans, mulchers, augers on combines, shafts, centrifuges, turbines, and many others rotors What is Synchronous Averaging? Signal Enhancement • Portable balancer, vibration analyzer "Balanset" for dynamic balancing crushers, fans, mulchers, augers on combines, shafts, centrifuges, turbines, and many others rotors

Understanding Synchronous Averaging

Definition: What is Synchronous Averaging?

Synchronous averaging (also called time-domain averaging or signal averaging) is a signal processing technique in vibration analysis that enhances periodic, speed-synchronous vibration components while suppressing random noise and asynchronous vibration. The method works by repeatedly sampling vibration over many shaft revolutions (triggered by a once-per-revolution tachometer signal), then averaging corresponding points in each revolution. Periodic components that repeat identically each revolution reinforce through averaging, while random noise and non-synchronous components cancel out, dramatically improving signal-to-noise ratio.

Synchronous averaging is particularly powerful for diagnosing gear problems (isolating individual gear mesh characteristics) and can reveal subtle periodic patterns buried in noise that would be invisible in standard time waveforms or FFT spectra.

How Synchronous Averaging Works

The Process

  1. Trigger Signal: Once-per-revolution pulse from tachometer or keyphasor defines start of each revolution
  2. Data Segmentation: Vibration signal divided into equal-length segments, one per revolution
  3. Alignment: All segments aligned to trigger pulse (same starting point)
  4. Point-by-Point Averaging: Corresponding points in each segment averaged together
  5. Result: Single averaged waveform representing one revolution
  6. Noise Reduction: Random components cancel; periodic components reinforce

Mathematical Basis

  • Periodic signals sum coherently (add in phase)
  • Random noise sums incoherently (cancels statistically)
  • Signal-to-noise improvement ∝ √N, where N = number of averages
  • Example: 100 averages improve SNR by 10× (20 dB)

Applications

1. Gearbox Diagnostics

Most common and powerful application:

Gear Mesh Isolation

  • Average synchronously with gear of interest
  • Enhances that gear’s mesh pattern
  • Suppresses other gears and bearings
  • Reveals individual tooth defects

Tooth-by-Tooth Analysis

  • Averaged waveform shows each tooth engagement clearly
  • Damaged tooth appears as deviation in pattern
  • Can identify which specific tooth is damaged
  • Severity assessment from deviation magnitude

2. Bearing Analysis Enhancement

  • Average over outer race period for outer race defect isolation
  • Enhances periodic impacts from bearing defects
  • Reduces masking from other vibration sources
  • Particularly useful in high-noise environments

3. Torsional Vibration

  • Enhance torsional components synchronous with rotation
  • Suppress lateral vibration and noise
  • Reveal torsional resonances and excitation

4. Balancing

Advantages

Noise Reduction

  • Dramatic improvement in signal-to-noise ratio
  • Can extract signals buried 20-30 dB below noise
  • Makes measurements possible in harsh environments

Fault Isolation

  • Separates one component’s signature from others
  • Example: isolate pinion mesh from gear mesh in gearbox
  • Identifies which component is defective

Enhanced Resolution

  • Reveals subtle patterns and defects
  • Shows details masked in raw signal
  • Enables early fault detection

Requirements and Limitations

Requirements

  • Tachometer: Reliable once-per-revolution trigger essential
  • Constant Speed: Speed must be relatively constant (±1-2%)
  • Sufficient Averages: Typically 50-200 revolutions for good results
  • Periodic Signal: Only enhances truly periodic components

Limitations

  • Suppresses Non-Synchronous Faults: Random defects, most bearing faults reduced
  • Speed Variations: Speed changes during averaging blur results
  • Time Required: Must collect data over many revolutions
  • Not Real-Time: Post-processing required

Comparison with Other Techniques

Synchronous Averaging vs. Linear Averaging

  • Synchronous: Averages in time domain, synchronous with rotation, enhances periodic
  • Linear: Averages FFT spectra, reduces random variation in all frequencies
  • Use Cases: Synchronous for gears; linear for general spectrum smoothing

Synchronous Averaging vs. Envelope Analysis

  • Synchronous Averaging: Time domain, enhances periodic patterns
  • Envelope Analysis: Frequency domain, detects repetitive impacts
  • Complementary: Can combine both for comprehensive analysis

Practical Implementation

Setup

  • Install tachometer with clear once-per-revolution pulse
  • Set number of averages (50-200 typical)
  • Define signal length (1 revolution, 10 revolutions, etc.)
  • Verify speed stability

Data Collection

  • Acquire vibration data over averaging period
  • Instrument automatically segments and averages
  • Display averaged waveform
  • Often compute FFT of averaged signal (enhanced spectrum)

Interpretation

  • Examine averaged waveform for periodic patterns
  • Look for deviations indicating defects
  • Compare to known-good signatures
  • Quantify defect severity from deviation amplitude

Advanced Variations

Gear-Synchronous Averaging

  • Trigger from gear of interest (not shaft)
  • Shows mesh pattern for that specific gear
  • Requires encoder or multi-pulse tachometer

Multi-Order Averaging

  • Average multiple orders simultaneously
  • Separate 1×, 2×, 3× components
  • Provides comprehensive order content

Difference Signal

  • Subtract averaged signal from raw signal
  • Residual shows what was removed (asynchronous components)
  • Useful for identifying bearing defects after removing gear mesh

Synchronous averaging is a sophisticated signal processing technique that dramatically enhances the visibility of periodic, speed-synchronous vibration patterns while suppressing noise and asynchronous components. Mastering synchronous averaging enables advanced gearbox diagnostics, early defect detection in noisy environments, and isolation of specific component signatures in complex machinery.


← Back to Main Index

Categories:

WhatsApp