Understanding Seal Defects in Rotating Machinery

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,336.95 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,336.95.$2,011.55Trenutna cijena je: $2,011.55.

Parts

Vibration sensor

$106.49 Izvorna cijena bila je: $106.49.$82.83Trenutna cijena je: $82.83.

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$146.72 Izvorna cijena bila je: $146.72.$106.49Trenutna cijena je: $106.49.

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,049.74

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.43

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.83

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,052.96 Izvorna cijena bila je: $2,052.96.$1,774.90Trenutna cijena je: $1,774.90.

Definition: What are Seal Defects?

Seal defects are damage, wear, or failures in sealing components that prevent lubricant leakage and exclude contaminants from rotating machinery. Common seal types include lip seals (radial shaft seals), mechanical face seals, labyrinth seals, and O-rings. Seal defects manifest as oil or grease leakage, ingress of dirt and moisture, increased friction and heating, and in some cases, contribution to vibration through rubbing or creating instabilities.

While seals may seem like minor components, their failure has serious consequences: loss of lubrication leads to rapid bearing failure, contamination ingress accelerates wear, and in process equipment (pumps), seal failure can result in product loss, environmental contamination, or safety hazards.

Common Seal Types and Their Defects

1. Lip Seals (Radial Shaft Seals)

Elastomeric seals with flexible lip contacting rotating shaft:

Common Defects

• Lip Wear: Friction wears lip material, eventually losing sealing contact
• Hardening: Heat or age hardens elastomer, lip loses flexibility and conformability
• Cracking: Cracks in lip from age, chemicals, or excessive shaft runout
• Lip Tearing: Damage from installation, shaft defects, or excessive vibration
• Garter Spring Loss: Spring maintaining lip contact breaks or falls off

Symptoms

• Oil or grease leakage at shaft exit points
• Contamination entry (dirt visible in bearing area)
• Bearing temperature increase from lubricant loss
• Bearing vibration increase from contamination

2. Mechanical Face Seals

Used in pumps and high-pressure applications:

Common Defects

• Face Wear: Mating faces wear, increasing leakage
• Face Damage: Scratches, chips, thermal cracks on sealing faces
• O-Ring Failure: Secondary seals deteriorate
• Spring Failure: Springs providing face pressure break or weaken
• Coking/Deposits: Material buildup preventing proper face contact

Symptoms

• Visible leakage at seal
• Steam or vapor emission (if sealing hot fluids)
• Squealing noise from face contact
• High seal temperature
• Vibration from face contact instability

3. Labyrinth Seals

Non-contact seals in turbines and compressors:

Common Defects

• Tooth Wear: Labyrinth teeth worn or broken from rubs
• Clearance Increase: Wear or thermal growth increases clearance, reducing sealing effectiveness
• Rubs: Contact from excessive vibration or shaft motion damages teeth
• Deposits: Carbon or scale buildup affecting clearances

Symptoms

• Increased leakage (measurable flow or pressure loss)
• Efficiency reduction (internal leakage)
• Vibration from rubs (may trigger steam whirl in some cases)
• Evidence of contact (wear marks, heat discoloration)

4. O-Rings and Static Seals

• Compression Set: Permanent deformation from sustained compression
• Chemical Attack: Incompatible fluids degrading elastomer
• Extrusion: O-ring squeezed out of groove under pressure
• Thermal Damage: Heat aging, hardening, cracking

Causes of Seal Failure

Normal Wear

• Contact seals have finite life from friction wear
• Typical lip seal life: 5,000-20,000 operating hours
• Mechanical seal life: 10,000-50,000 hours depending on application
• Wear rate depends on shaft surface, speed, lubrication

Installation Damage

• Seal lip cut or damaged during installation
• Seal not properly seated in housing
• Shaft surface defects tearing seal lip
• Contamination during assembly

Operating Conditions

• Excessive Shaft Runout: Shaft eccentricity or vibration exceeding seal capability
• High Temperature: Degrading elastomeric materials
• Chemical Incompatibility: Process fluids attacking seal materials
• Abrasive Environment: Particles damaging seal faces
• Dry Running: Loss of lubrication to seal causing rapid wear

Mechanical Issues

• Excessive vibration from unbalance or misalignment
• Shaft defects (scratches, scoring) damaging seal lips
• Bearing failure allowing excessive shaft motion
• Thermal growth affecting seal fit

Detection of Seal Defects

Visual Indicators

• Leakage: Oil, grease, or process fluid visible at seal location
• Staining: Discoloration around seal from seepage
• Dripping: Active leakage pooling below equipment
• Misting: Fine spray from high-pressure seal leakage

Operational Indicators

• Lubricant Loss: Frequent need to add oil or grease
• Contamination: Dirt or moisture in lubricant samples
• Bearing Problems: Premature bearing wear from contamination or lubricant loss
• Temperature Rise: Bearing heating from inadequate lubrication

Vibration Effects

• Seal rubs can create friction-induced vibration
• High-frequency components from seal contact
• In severe cases, sub-synchronous vibration from seal instability
• Secondary effects: bearing vibration from contamination or lubrication loss

Consequences of Seal Failure

Immediate Effects

• Lubricant loss requiring frequent replenishment
• Contamination entry degrading remaining lubricant
• Product loss or environmental release (process seals)
• Safety hazards from slippery floors or toxic material release

Secondary Damage

• Bearing Failure: Inadequate lubrication or contamination destroys bearings
• Accelerated Wear: Abrasive contamination accelerates all wear
• Corrosion: Moisture ingress causes rust and corrosion
• Coupling Damage: Lubricant spray contaminates elastomeric coupling elements

Prevention and Maintenance

Proper Selection

• Select seal type appropriate for application (pressure, temperature, speed, chemical compatibility)
• Use correct seal size and specification
• Consider shaft surface finish requirements (typically < 0.8 µm Ra for lip seals)
• Match elastomer to fluid and temperature (Nitrile, Viton, PTFE, etc.)

Installation Practices

• Clean all surfaces before installation
• Use proper installation tools (seal drivers, not hammers)
• Lubricate seal lips before installation
• Protect seal lip when sliding over shaft (use installation sleeve)
• Verify seal squareness and proper seating

Operating Practices

• Maintain good balance and alignment (reduce shaft motion and vibration)
• Control operating temperatures within seal rating
• Ensure adequate lubrication reaching seal
• Avoid contaminating seal area with incompatible materials

Preventive Replacement

• Replace seals during scheduled maintenance (don’t wait for failure)
• Typical replacement intervals: 2-5 years or per manufacturer recommendation
• Always replace seals when opening bearing housings
• Keep seal kits in spare parts inventory

Special Considerations

High-Vibration Equipment

• Excessive shaft motion damages seals rapidly
• Must address vibration root causes to achieve acceptable seal life
• Consider heavy-duty or spring-loaded seals for high-vibration applications

Extreme Environments

• High Temperature: Use high-temperature elastomers or mechanical seals
• Abrasive: Protective shaft sleeves, expeller seals to exclude particles
• Corrosive: Chemical-resistant materials, coated surfaces
• Vacuum: Special low-outgassing seals

Troubleshooting Seal Problems

Premature Seal Failure

Investigation Areas:

• Verify shaft surface condition (roughness, scratches, corrosion)
• Check shaft runout (excessive runout kills seals quickly)
• Measure vibration levels (high vibration reduces seal life)
• Verify operating temperature within seal rating
• Check for chemical incompatibility
• Examine installation practices
• Verify correct seal type and size for application

Persistent Leakage

Possible Causes and Solutions:

• Shaft Damage: Groove worn in shaft at seal location → repair shaft or use repair sleeve
• Excessive Runout: Shaft eccentricity → correct runout or use higher-capacity seal
• Wrong Seal Orientation: Seal installed backward → reinstall correctly
• Seal Lip Damaged: Installation damage → replace and use proper technique
• Incorrect Pressure: Pressure exceeding seal rating → use pressure-rated seal or reduce pressure

Seal-Related Vibration Issues

Seal Friction and Instability

• Contact seals can create stick-slip friction
• May contribute to low-frequency vibration or chatter
• Dry running seals particularly prone to friction vibration
• Non-contact seals (labyrinth) can create aerodynamic instabilities

Seal Rub

• Excessive shaft motion causes seal-to-shaft hard contact
• Generates heat, damages seal rapidly
• Can create thermal bow from asymmetric heating
• May produce high-frequency vibration and noise

Impact on Machine Reliability

Lubrication System Integrity

• Seals are critical boundary of lubrication system
• Seal failure leads to lubricant loss and contamination entry
• Results in rapid bearing deterioration
• Can cascade to complete machine failure

Environmental Protection

• Seals prevent process fluid leakage (pumps, compressors)
• Failure can cause environmental contamination
• Safety concerns with toxic or flammable materials
• Regulatory compliance issues

Modern Seal Technologies

Advanced Designs

• Multi-Lip Seals: Multiple sealing lips for redundancy
• Expeller Seals: Centrifugal action excludes contaminants
• Magnetic Seals: Magnetic fluid sealed by magnetic field
• Dry Gas Seals: Non-contact seals for high-speed compressors
• Cartridge Seals: Pre-assembled units simplifying installation

Condition Monitoring

• Seal leak detection systems
• Flush fluid flow monitoring (mechanical seals)
• Temperature monitoring at seal location
• Vibration monitoring detecting seal-related issues

Seal defects, while often overlooked compared to bearing or rotor problems, have critical impacts on machinery reliability. Proper seal selection, installation, and preventive replacement combined with addressing root causes of premature failure (vibration, runout, contamination) ensures seals perform their essential functions of lubrication retention and contamination exclusion throughout their design life.

---

← Back to Main Index