Understanding Resonance in Mechanical Systems

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

€1,975.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Vibration sensor

€90.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

€124.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Devices

Balanset-4

€6,803.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

€46.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Reflective tape

€10.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

€1,735.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Resonance is a physical phenomenon that occurs when a system is subjected to a periodic force at a frequency that matches one of its own natural frequencies. When that frequency match happens, the system begins to vibrate with extremely large amplitudes: energy from the input force is transferred into the system with great efficiency, so the vibration builds up dramatically cycle after cycle. The only factor that ultimately limits the amplitude at resonance is the system’s damping. Understanding and avoiding resonance is one of the central tasks of rotor dynamics and machinery diagnostics, because few conditions can destroy equipment as quickly.

1. Definition: What is Resonance?

Resonance is best understood as a question of timing, not force. A modest excitation, applied in step with a structure’s own rhythm, will produce a far larger response than a much stronger force applied out of step. Each well-timed input adds a little more energy than damping can remove during that cycle, so the amplitude grows until the energy dissipated by damping per cycle finally balances the energy supplied. In a lightly damped system that balance point is reached only at a very high amplitude — which is why resonance is dangerous. The frequency at which it occurs is the natural frequency, set entirely by the system’s mass and stiffness.

2. The Link Between Natural Frequency and Resonance

To understand resonance you must first understand natural frequency. Every physical object has a set of natural frequencies at which it will vibrate freely if disturbed, determined by its mass and its stiffness. Resonance is simply what happens when you continuously “push” the object at the exact rate of one of those natural frequencies.

The classic analogy is pushing a child on a swing:

• The swing, with the child aboard, has a specific natural frequency set by the rope length (its stiffness) and the child’s mass.
• A single push makes it oscillate at that natural frequency and slowly die away because of damping — air resistance and friction.
• If you time each push to match the swing’s natural frequency, every push adds energy and the swing goes higher and higher. That is resonance.
• If you push at the wrong rate — too fast or too slow — your pushes fall out of sync with the motion and no large amplitude can build.

The same mass-and-stiffness relationship governs machine components. You can explore it quantitatively with our Natural Frequency calculator for a simple mass-spring system, or, for rotating shafts where the natural frequency coincides with running speed, the Rotor Critical Speed calculator.

3. Why is Resonance a Problem in Machinery?

In rotating machinery, resonance is a highly destructive and dangerous condition. The “push” is supplied by any periodic force the machine generates in normal operation — unbalance, misalignment, or blade-pass forces among them. If the frequency of one of these forces aligns with a natural frequency of the rotor, the foundation, the support structure or attached piping, the consequences can be severe:

• Extreme vibration levels: amplitudes can be amplified ten, fifty or even hundreds of times, depending on how little damping is present.
• High dynamic stresses: the large deflections impose immense cyclic stress on components, driving rapid fatigue.
• Catastrophic failure: resonance can produce cracked shafts, failed bearings, broken welds and complete structural failure in a remarkably short time.
• Excessive noise: the high vibration radiates as loud, often tonal, noise.

A special and especially important case is the critical speed — a rotor speed at which the running-speed (1×) excitation coincides with a rotor natural frequency. Machines are deliberately designed to run away from their critical speeds, and to pass through them quickly during run-up and coast-down.

4. Symptoms and Identification of Resonance

Resonance has a distinct set of symptoms that aid diagnosis and distinguish it from a simple forced-vibration problem like plain unbalance:

• Highly directional vibration: the vibration is typically much higher in one direction — often horizontal — than in others, because structural stiffness differs by direction.
• Sharp peak in vibration versus speed: the vibration is high only within a narrow speed band; as the machine speeds up or slows past that point the amplitude falls away dramatically.
• A 180-degree phase shift: as the speed sweeps through the resonant frequency, the phase of the vibration shifts by 180 degrees. This phase reversal is the definitive confirmation of resonance.
• Difficult to balance: trying to balance a rotor operating on a resonance is often ineffective or can make matters worse — the required correction weights come out unusually large or small, and the vibration may simply migrate to a different location.

Resonance is confirmed experimentally in two complementary ways. A bump (impact) test excites the stationary structure to reveal its natural frequencies directly. Alternatively, a run-up or coast-down test records amplitude and phase as the machine sweeps through the suspected resonance, with the tell-tale amplitude peak and 180-degree phase shift plotted on a Bode plot.

5. How to Solve a Resonance Problem

Because resonance is fundamentally a frequency-matching problem, every solution comes down to changing the frequency of either the “pusher” or the “pushee” — or to dissipating the energy faster:

1. Change the forcing frequency. Usually this means changing the machine’s operating speed. It is the simplest fix where the process allows it, and on variable-speed drives a forbidden speed band can be programmed out.
2. Change the natural frequency. This is the most common solution.
   • To increase the natural frequency, increase the stiffness of the resonant component — for example by adding a brace or a gusset.
   • To decrease the natural frequency, either decrease the stiffness or add mass to the component.
3. Add damping. Where neither frequency can be moved, adding damping — viscoelastic treatments or specialised dampers — reduces the height of the resonant peak to an acceptable level. The benefit of added damping can be quantified with a Damping Ratio calculator.

It is worth noting that resonance involving the support system — structural resonance or weak foundation stiffness — is a frequent culprit and is addressed the same way, by stiffening, adding mass, or damping the offending member.

6. Resonance and Field Balancing

The link between resonance and balancing is a practical trap worth avoiding. Because a rotor operating near a resonance gives misleading, unstable amplitude-and-phase readings, you must first establish that the machine is not running on a resonance before you attempt to balance it. In the field this is straightforward with a portable two-channel analyser such as the Balanset-1A: its run-up and coast-down measurement captures the amplitude and phase across the speed range, exposing any resonant peak and 180-degree phase shift, while its laser tachometer supplies the phase reference. Once the machine is confirmed to run comfortably away from resonance, the same instrument computes the correction weights and verifies the result against the appropriate balancing tolerance — whereas attempting the correction on a resonance would only chase the symptom.

← Back to Main Index