Understanding Self-Excited Vibration

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

€1,975.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Vibration sensor

€90.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

€124.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Devices

Balanset-4

€6,803.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

€46.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Parts

Reflective tape

€10.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

€1,735.00 + VAT (if applicable)

Self-excited vibration — also called self-induced or unstable vibration — is a particularly dangerous class of motion in which the movement of a system generates the very forces that sustain or amplify that movement. The result is a closed feedback loop: the vibration creates its own driving force, so the amplitude can grow, sometimes to a catastrophic level, with no increase whatsoever in any external excitation. It is the mechanism behind several of the most feared instabilities in rotor dynamics, and recognising it quickly is a core diagnostic skill.

This is fundamentally different from a forced vibration such as unbalance or misalignment, where the vibration is a direct, proportional response to a specific periodic input at a known forcing frequency. Double the unbalance and you double the response; remove the forcing and the vibration stops. In a self-excited system there is no such external clock — the motion feeds itself, and the energy that drives it is drawn from a steady source such as rotation, fluid flow or a cutting process.

1. The Feedback Loop Mechanism

The mechanism of a self-excited vibration can be set out as a sequence:

1. A system — say a rotor turning in its bearing — is in steady motion.
2. A small, random disturbance produces a slight displacement or change in velocity.
3. That change in motion alters the forces acting on the system — for example the fluid pressure in a journal bearing or the cutting force on a tool.
4. Critically, the altered force acts so as to add energy to the system, pushing the component further in the direction it was already moving.
5. The increased motion generates an even larger force, which adds yet more energy — and the cycle repeats.

The loop drives the amplitude upward until it is checked by non-linearities in the system (the rotor hitting a hard stop, a seal closing a clearance) or until something fails. The key physical insight is one of energy balance: an instability arises whenever the motion-dependent force pumps in energy faster than the system’s damping can dissipate it. Adequate damping is therefore the first line of defence against self-excitation.

2. Common Examples of Self-Excited Vibration

Several well-known phenomena in machinery diagnostics are textbook cases of self-excited vibration:

• Oil whirl and oil whip: the most common examples in rotating machinery. In a fluid-film journal bearing the rotating shaft drags oil into a load-carrying wedge. A disturbance can set the wedge itself orbiting (whirling) around the bearing; the pressure from that whirling wedge shoves the shaft, adding more energy to the whirl. The resulting vibration is not at running speed but at a sub-synchronous frequency, typically 0.42–0.48× running speed. If the whirl frequency drifts up to coincide with a rotor natural frequency, it locks on and escalates into the far more violent whip condition.
• Chatter in machining: in turning or milling, chatter begins when the cutting tool starts to vibrate. That vibration makes the thickness of the chip vary, the varying chip thickness makes the cutting force fluctuate, and the fluctuating force pumps energy back into the tool’s vibration — growing it into a violent, self-sustaining chatter that wrecks the surface finish and the tool.
• Aerodynamic flutter: the coupled bending-and-twisting vibration of an aircraft wing (or a turbine blade) in which the motion changes the aerodynamic profile, the changed profile alters the air pressure, and the altered pressure feeds energy back into the motion — leading to catastrophic failure if it is not controlled.
• Rotor rubs: when a rotor contacts a stationary part, friction at the rub heats the rotor locally and bows it. The bow increases the rubbing force, which increases the heat and the bow, creating a thermal feedback loop that can spiral into a seizure.

Two further fluid-driven cousins worth knowing are steam whirl in turbines and the broader family of flow-induced instabilities driven by aerodynamic forces, both of which obey the same energy-feedback logic.

3. Self-Excited vs. Forced Vibration at a Glance

4. Key Characteristics and Diagnosis

Self-excited vibrations tend to leave distinctive fingerprints in the FFT spectrum:

• Non-synchronous frequencies: the vibration is usually not an integer multiple or harmonic of running speed. It commonly sits at a sub-synchronous frequency.
• Instability: the amplitude can be highly erratic and may surge rapidly with small changes in speed, temperature or load.
• Sudden onset: the vibration may be entirely absent until the machine crosses a particular speed or load threshold — often related to a critical speed — at which point it appears abruptly and at high amplitude.

Diagnosis means identifying those characteristic non-synchronous peaks and then reasoning about the physical mechanism that could produce such an instability in the specific machine. Because the onset is tied to operating conditions, a speed-varying record is especially revealing: a cascade plot taken during run-up or coast-down shows a sub-synchronous component appearing and then locking onto a natural frequency, which is the unmistakable signature of whirl turning into whip. For bearing-related cases, a journal-bearing defect-frequency calculator helps confirm whether a suspect peak falls in the oil-whirl band. The umbrella term for this whole behaviour is rotor instability, and distinguishing it from a forced response is the analyst’s first and most important branch point — because the cure is completely different: forced vibration is reduced by balancing or alignment, whereas a self-excited instability must be designed out by changing bearing geometry, clearance, load or damping.

5. Why It Cannot Be Balanced Away

A practical warning follows directly from the physics. Because a self-excited vibration is not a response to a rotating heavy spot, it cannot be cured by adding correction weights — the energy is being supplied by the bearing fluid, the cutting process or the airflow, not by a mass imbalance. This is exactly why a careful field measurement matters before any corrective work: when an engineer captures amplitude and phase with a portable two-channel analyser such as the Balanset-1A, a stable, repeatable 1× vector points to a genuine balancing problem, whereas a drifting, sub-synchronous, non-repeating component is a red flag that the fault is an instability and that balancing would waste effort. Reading the analyser correctly therefore prevents the classic mistake of trying to balance out a whirl.

← Back to Main Index