Understanding Nodal Points in Rotor Vibration

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,353.83

Parts

Vibration sensor

$107.26

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$147.78

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,107.90

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.82

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.92

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,067.80

Definition: What is a Nodal Point?

A nodal point (also called a node or nodal line when considering three-dimensional motion) is a specific location along a vibrating rotor where the displacement or deflection remains zero during vibration at a particular natural frequency. Even as the rest of the shaft vibrates and deflects, the nodal point remains stationary relative to the shaft’s neutral position.

Nodal points are fundamental features of mode shapes, and their locations provide critical information for rotor dynamics analysis, balancing procedures, and sensor placement strategies.

Nodal Points in Different Vibration Modes

First Bending Mode

The first (fundamental) bending mode typically has:

• Zero Internal Nodes: No points of zero deflection along the shaft length
• Bearing Locations as Approximate Nodes: In simply-supported configurations, bearings act as near-nodal points
• Maximum Deflection: Typically near mid-span between bearings
• Simple Arc Shape: Shaft bends in single smooth curve

Second Bending Mode

The second mode has a more complex pattern:

• One Internal Node: A single point along the shaft (typically near mid-span) where deflection is zero
• S-Curve Shape: Shaft bends in opposite directions on either side of the node
• Two Antinodes: Maximum deflections occur on either side of the nodal point
• Higher Frequency: Natural frequency significantly higher than first mode

Third Mode and Higher

• Third Mode: Two internal nodal points, three antinodes
• Fourth Mode: Three nodal points, four antinodes
• General Rule: Mode N has (N-1) internal nodal points
• Increasing Complexity: Higher modes show progressively more complex wave patterns

Physical Significance of Nodal Points

Zero Deflection

At a nodal point during vibration at that mode’s natural frequency:

• Lateral displacement is zero
• The shaft passes through its neutral axis
• However, bending stress is typically maximum (slope of deflection curve is maximum)
• Shear forces are maximum at nodes

Zero Sensitivity

Forces or masses applied at nodal points have minimal effect on that particular mode:

• Adding correction weights at nodes doesn’t effectively balance that mode
• Sensors placed at nodes detect minimal vibration for that mode
• Supports or constraints at nodes minimally affect the mode’s natural frequency

Practical Implications for Balancing

Correction Plane Selection

Understanding nodal point locations guides balancing strategy:

For Rigid Rotors

• Operating below first critical speed
• First mode not significantly excited
• Standard two-plane balancing near rotor ends is effective
• Nodal points not a primary concern

For Flexible Rotors

• Operating through or above critical speeds
• Must consider mode shapes and nodal points
• Effective Correction Planes: Should be at or near antinode locations (maximum deflection points)
• Ineffective Locations: Correction planes at or near nodes have minimal effect on that mode
• Modal Balancing: Explicitly accounts for nodal point locations when distributing correction weights

Example: Second Mode Balancing

Consider a long flexible shaft operating above first critical speed, exciting second mode:

• Second mode has one nodal point near mid-span
• Placing all correction weight near mid-span (the node) would be ineffective
• Optimal strategy: Place corrections at the two antinode locations (on either side of the node)
• Weight distribution pattern must match second mode shape for effective balancing

Sensor Placement Considerations

Vibration Measurement Strategy

Nodal points critically affect vibration monitoring:

Avoid Nodal Locations

• Sensors at nodes detect minimal vibration for that mode
• May miss significant vibration problems if only measuring at nodes
• Can give false impression of acceptable vibration levels

Target Antinode Locations

• Maximum vibration amplitude at antinodes
• Most sensitive to developing problems
• Typically at bearing locations for first mode
• For higher modes, may require intermediate measurement points

Multiple Measurement Points

• For flexible rotors, measure at several axial locations
• Ensures no mode is missed due to nodal positioning
• Allows experimental determination of mode shapes
• Critical equipment often has sensors at every bearing plus mid-span

Determining Nodal Point Locations

Analytical Prediction

• Finite Element Analysis: Calculates mode shapes and identifies nodal points
• Beam Theory: For simple configurations, analytical solutions predict node locations
• Design Tools: Rotor dynamics software provides visual mode shape displays with nodes marked

Experimental Identification

1. Impact (Bump) Testing

• Strike shaft at multiple locations with instrumented hammer
• Measure response at multiple points
• Locations showing no response at a particular frequency are nodal points for that mode

2. Operating Deflection Shape Measurement

• During operation near critical speed, measure vibration at many axial locations
• Plot deflection amplitude vs. position
• Zero-crossing points are nodal locations

3. Proximity Probe Arrays

• Multiple non-contact sensors along shaft length
• Directly measure shaft deflection during startup/coastdown
• Most accurate experimental method for identifying nodes

Nodal Points vs. Antinodes

Nodal points and antinodes are complementary concepts:

Nodal Points

• Zero deflection
• Maximum bending slope and stress
• Low effectiveness for force application or measurement
• Ideal for support locations (minimize transmitted force)

Antinodes

• Maximum deflection
• Zero bending slope
• Maximum effectiveness for correction weights
• Optimal sensor placement locations
• Highest stress locations (for combined loading)

Practical Applications and Case Studies

Case: Paper Machine Roll

• Situation: Long (6 meter) roll operating at 1200 RPM, high vibration
• Analysis: Operating above first critical, exciting second mode with node at mid-span
• Initial Balancing Attempt: Weights added at mid-span (convenient access) with poor results
• Solution: Recognition that mid-span was nodal point; weights redistributed to quarter-points (antinodes)
• Result: Vibration reduced by 85%, successful modal balancing

Case: Steam Turbine Monitoring

• Situation: New vibration monitoring system showing low vibration despite known unbalance
• Investigation: Sensor inadvertently placed near nodal point of dominant mode
• Solution: Additional sensors at antinode locations revealed actual vibration levels
• Lesson: Always consider mode shapes when designing monitoring systems

Advanced Considerations

Moving Nodes

In some systems, nodal points shift with operating conditions:

• Speed-dependent bearing stiffness changes node locations
• Temperature effects on shaft stiffness
• Load-dependent response
• Asymmetric systems may have different nodes for horizontal and vertical motion

Approximate vs. True Nodes

• True Nodes: Exact zero deflection points in ideal systems
• Approximate Nodes: Locations of very low (but not zero) deflection in real systems with damping and other non-ideal effects
• Practical Consideration: Real nodes are regions of low deflection rather than exact mathematical points

Understanding nodal points provides crucial insight into rotor vibration behavior and is essential for effective balancing of flexible rotors, optimal sensor placement, and proper interpretation of vibration data in rotating machinery.

---

← Back to Main Index