Understanding Overhung Rotors

Devices

Portable balancer & Vibration analyzer Balanset-1A

$2,353.83

Parts

Vibration sensor

$107.26

Parts

Optical Sensor (Laser Tachometer)

$147.78

Devices

Balanset-4

$8,107.90

Parts

Magnetic Stand Insize-60-kgf

$54.82

Parts

Reflective tape

$11.92

Devices

Dynamic balancer “Balanset-1A” OEM

$2,067.80

Definition: What is an Overhung Rotor?

An overhung rotor (also called a cantilever rotor or cantilevered rotor) is a rotor configuration where the rotating mass extends outward beyond the supporting bearings, mounted in a cantilevered fashion. In this design, the rotor is supported on one side only, with the working element (impeller, fan wheel, grinding wheel, etc.) overhanging from the bearing support, rather than being positioned between two bearings.

This configuration is common in many types of industrial equipment and presents unique challenges for balancing due to the amplification of unbalance forces through the cantilever action.

Common Examples of Overhung Rotors

Overhung rotor designs are widespread in industrial and commercial applications:

HVAC and Industrial Fans

• Centrifugal blower impellers extending from motor shafts
• Axial cooling fans mounted on motor end bells
• Pedestal-mounted industrial fans

Pumps

• Single-stage centrifugal pump impellers
• Close-coupled pumps where the impeller extends from the motor bearing

Machine Tools

• Grinding wheels on overhung spindles
• Milling cutters and tool holders
• Lathe chucks

Power Transmission

• Pulleys and sheaves mounted on motor shafts
• Gear wheels on extended shafts
• Chain sprockets

Processing Equipment

• Mixer agitators and impellers
• Turbine blades on turbine shafts

Why the Overhung Design?

Despite the balancing challenges, overhung rotors offer significant practical advantages:

1. Accessibility

The working element is easily accessible for inspection, maintenance, and replacement without disassembling the entire machine or disturbing the bearings.

2. Simplicity and Cost

Eliminating one bearing support reduces mechanical complexity, part count, and manufacturing cost.

3. Space Efficiency

The compact design requires less axial space than a between-bearings arrangement.

4. Easy Mounting

Components can often be mounted directly onto standard motor shafts or existing machinery without custom coupling arrangements.

5. Process Requirements

In some applications (pumps, mixers, chemical processing), having the working element on only one side is necessary to access the process fluid or material.

Unique Balancing Challenges

Overhung rotors present several challenges that make them more sensitive to unbalance than between-bearing designs:

1. Moment Amplification

Any unbalance in an overhung rotor creates not just a centrifugal force, but also a moment (torque) about the bearing support. The farther the mass is from the bearings, the larger this moment, amplifying the effect of even small unbalances. This is described by the lever arm principle: Force × Distance = Moment.

2. High Bearing Loads

The cantilever configuration imposes high radial and moment loads on the bearings, particularly the bearing closest to the rotor. Unbalance exacerbates these loads, accelerating bearing wear.

3. Shaft Bending and Deflection

The cantilevered shaft is subject to bending forces, and even small unbalances can cause significant shaft deflection at the overhung end, especially at higher speeds or with longer overhang distances.

4. Coupling and Keyway Effects

Many overhung rotors are mounted on motor shafts via keys, set screws, or couplings. These connections can introduce or change the unbalance condition, and any looseness dramatically worsens vibration.

5. Sensitivity to Installation

Improper mounting (not fully seated on shaft, cocked at an angle, loose fasteners) has a more pronounced effect on overhung rotors than on between-bearing designs.

Balancing Considerations for Overhung Rotors

Single-Plane Usually Sufficient

Most overhung rotors are relatively short in the axial direction and can be effectively balanced using single-plane balancing. The correction plane is typically located on the rotor itself at the most accessible location.

Static vs. Dynamic Balance

• Static Balance: Ensures the rotor’s center of mass lies on the axis of rotation. For disc-shaped overhung rotors, static balance is often adequate.
• Dynamic Balance: For longer overhung rotors or those with significant axial thickness, dynamic balancing in two planes may be necessary to eliminate couple unbalance.

Overhang Distance Matters

The greater the overhang distance (distance from the nearest bearing to the rotor’s center of mass), the more critical balance quality becomes. As a general rule:

• Short overhang (L/D < 0.3): Less sensitive, standard balance tolerances apply
• Moderate overhang (0.3 < L/D < 0.7): More sensitive, consider tighter tolerances
• Long overhang (L/D > 0.7): Highly sensitive, requires careful balancing and may need dynamic balance

Where L is overhang length and D is rotor diameter.

Best Practices for Overhung Rotor Balancing

1. Balance in Final Installed Configuration When Possible

Overhung rotors are particularly sensitive to how they’re mounted. Ideally, perform field balancing with the rotor installed on its shaft, in its final operating configuration.

2. Verify Secure Mounting

Before balancing, ensure:

• All mounting fasteners (set screws, bolts, keys) are properly tightened
• The rotor is fully seated on the shaft with no gaps
• Any keyways are properly fitted without excessive clearance
• The rotor is perpendicular to the shaft (not cocked or angled)

3. Use Appropriate Correction Radius

Place correction weights at as large a radius as practical (typically near the outer diameter). This maximizes the effect of each gram of correction weight, allowing for smaller weight additions.

4. Check for Run-Out

Measure shaft run-out before balancing. Excessive run-out (eccentricity, wobble, bent shaft) will prevent achieving good balance and must be corrected first.

5. Consider Moment Effects in Vibration Measurement

When measuring vibration on overhung rotor installations, take readings at both the drive end and the non-drive end bearings if accessible. The vibration pattern will differ significantly between locations due to the moment created by the overhung mass.

6. Use Tighter Tolerances

Due to the amplification effects, consider specifying one G-grade tighter than would be used for an equivalent between-bearing rotor. For example, use G 2.5 instead of G 6.3 for critical applications.

Common Problems and Solutions

Problem: Vibration Returns After Balancing

Possible Causes:

• Loose mounting hardware worked loose during operation
• Correction weights shifted or fell off
• Material buildup or erosion changed balance state
• Thermal growth caused shifting

Solutions: Use thread-locking compounds, weld or permanently attach correction weights, establish regular inspection schedule.

Problem: Unable to Achieve Acceptable Balance

Possible Causes:

• Shaft run-out or bent shaft
• Bearing wear or excessive clearance
• Structural resonance at operating speed
• Poor rotor mounting (cocked, not fully seated)

Solutions: Address mechanical issues before balancing, check shaft straightness, replace worn bearings, verify proper mounting.

Design Considerations for New Equipment

When designing equipment with overhung rotors:

• Minimize Overhang: Keep the overhang distance as short as practical
• Stiffen the Shaft: Use larger diameter shafts to resist bending
• Use Robust Bearings: Specify bearings with adequate radial and moment load capacity
• Provide Balance Capability: Design correction planes or accessible locations for adding/removing balance weights
• Consider Pre-Balancing: Balance the rotor element before installation when possible
• Specify Appropriate Tolerances: Don’t over-specify, but recognize that overhung designs need good balance

Industry Standards and Guidelines

While overhung rotors don’t have separate balancing standards, they are covered by general balancing standards with special notes:

• ISO 21940-11: Provides G-grade selection guidance applicable to overhung rotors
• API 610 (Centrifugal Pumps): Specifies balance quality for overhung pump impellers
• ANSI/AGMA Standards: Provide guidance for balancing overhung gears and pulleys

Generally, apply standard balance grades but recognize that overhung configurations may benefit from one grade tighter to compensate for the amplification effects.

---

← Back to Main Index